盐胁迫下苦荞萌发期耐盐碱性评价及种质筛选

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1006.2026.51066

作物学报 ›› 2026, Vol. 52 ›› Issue (2): 459-479.doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2026.51066

• 作物遗传育种·种质资源·分子遗传学 • 上一篇下一篇

盐胁迫下苦荞萌发期耐盐碱性评价及种质筛选

黄丽霞¹^,²(), 张卫卫¹^,², 甄一越¹^,², 王秋宝³, 田洪岭³, 李国栋⁴, 刘龙龙¹, 张丽君¹^,^*()

¹山西农业大学农业基因资源研究中心, 山西太原 030031
²山西农业大学农学院, 山西晋中 030801
³山西农业大学经济作物研究所, 山西太原 030031
⁴长治市农业农村局, 山西长治 046000

收稿日期:2025-07-09 接受日期:2025-10-30 出版日期:2026-02-12 网络出版日期:2025-11-17
通讯作者: *张丽君 E-mail:15034054161@163.com
作者简介:E-mail: huanglixia0329@163.com
基金资助:
财政部和农业农村部国家现代农业产业技术体系建设专项(CARS-07-A-2);山西省重点研发计划项目(2022ZDYF110);山西省现代产业技术体系建设项目(2024CYJSTX03-11)

Evaluation of salinity tolerance and germplasm screening of buckwheat during germination under salt stress

Huang Li-Xia¹^,²(), Zhang Wei-Wei¹^,², Zhen Yi-Yue¹^,², Wang Qiu-Bao³, Tian Hong-Ling³, Li Guo-Dong⁴, Liu Long-Long¹, Zhang Li-Jun¹^,^*()

¹Research Center for Agricultural Genetic Resources, Shanxi Agricultural University, Taiyuan 030031, Shanxi, China
²College of Agriculture, Shanxi Agricultural University, Jinzhong 030801, Shanxi, China
³Research Institute of Economic Crops, Shanxi Agricultural University, Taiyuan 030031, Shanxi, China
⁴Changzhi Agricultural and Rural Bureau, Changzhi 046000, Shanxi, China

Received:2025-07-09 Accepted:2025-10-30 Published:2026-02-12 Published online:2025-11-17
Contact: *Zhang Li-Jun E-mail:15034054161@163.com
Supported by:
China Agriculture Research System of MOF and MARA(CARS-07-A-2);Shanxi Provincial Key Research and Development Program Project(2022ZDYF110);Shanxi Provincial Modern Industrial Technology System Construction Project(2024CYJSTX03-11)

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

土壤盐碱化是威胁全球农业可持续发展的关键非生物限制因子, 严重制约苦荞等耐逆作物的生产潜力。为了筛选苦荞耐盐碱种质资源以及建立耐盐碱评价模型, 以160份苦荞种质资源为材料, 采用双层滤纸法进行萌发期试验, 设置中性盐NaCl、Na₂SO₄与碱性盐NaHCO₃、Na₂CO₃各5个梯度胁迫, 测定发芽势(GP)等5个萌发参数、根长(RL)等4个生长指标, 计算各指标的耐盐指数。采用多元统计分析方法对苦荞耐盐性进行综合评价及耐盐指标的筛选。结果表明, 9个指标的耐盐系数在不同的盐种类间均存在不同程度的变异, 各单项指标间均存在一定的相关性, 碱性盐(NaHCO₃/Na₂CO₃)对苦荞萌发的抑制阈值(0.10%)显著低于中性盐(0.25%), 盐类的抑制强度排序为Na₂CO₃> NaHCO₃> Na₂SO₄≈NaCl (高浓度时)。通过主成分分析, 4种盐均从9个指标的耐盐系数中提取了2个主成分, 其累计方差贡献率达80.12%~84.07%, PC1 (萌发活力因子, 贡献率54.60%~58.13%)包含活力指数(VI)、发芽指数(GI)和发芽率(GR), PC2 (生物量因子, 贡献率25.21%~27.96%)包含鲜重(FW)、干重(DW)和芽长(SL)。利用隶属函数分析法计算160份苦荞种质资源的综合评价值(D值), 并在此基础上采用聚类分析, 将种质资源分为高耐(HT)、较耐(RT)、中等(MT)、敏感(SS)、极敏(HS) 5个等级, 筛选到14份种质在NaCl、Na₂SO₄、NaHCO₃和Na₂CO₃四种单盐胁迫下均表现出高耐特性。进一步利用逐步回归分析建立最优线性回归方程, NaCl、Na₂SO₄与NaHCO₃筛选出的VI、GI、FW、SL和GR与D值呈显著相关(R² = 0.994~0.999, P < 0.01), Na₂CO₃筛选出的GI、FW、SL和RL与D值呈显著相关(R² = 0.998, P < 0.01), 以上可作为耐盐的鉴定指标, 活力指数(VI)作为综合生理指标较传统发芽率具有更高的区分度。本研究结果为苦荞耐盐种质资源鉴定及后续开展全基因组关联分析(genome-wide association study, GWAS)挖掘耐盐碱相关的数量性状位点(quantitative trait locus, QTL) 及基因奠定了表型组学基础。

关键词: 苦荞, 萌发期, 耐盐性评价, 主成分分析, 聚类分析, 逐步回归分析

Abstract:

Soil salinization is a major abiotic stress factor threatening the sustainable development of global agriculture and severely limiting the production potential of buckwheat and other salt-sensitive crops. To screen salt-tolerant buckwheat germplasm and establish a reliable evaluation model, 160 buckwheat accessions were subjected to a germination test using the double-layer filter paper method. Two types of salt stress—neutral salts (NaCl, Na₂SO₄) and alkaline salts (NaHCO₃, Na₂CO₃)—were applied at five concentration gradients. Five germination parameters, including germination potential (GP), and four seedling growth traits, including root length (RL), were measured to calculate the salt tolerance index (STI) for each trait. Multivariate statistical analyses were conducted to comprehensively evaluate salt tolerance and identify key indicators. Results showed that the salt tolerance coefficients of the nine measured traits varied across salt types and concentrations, with significant correlations observed among some traits. The germination inhibition threshold for alkaline salts (0.10%) was significantly lower than that for neutral salts (0.25%), and the inhibition strength followed the order: Na₂CO₃ > NaHCO₃ > Na₂SO₄ ≈ NaCl (at high concentrations). Principal component analysis (PCA) extracted two principal components from the nine STI traits for each salt type, explaining 80.12%-84.07% of the total variance. PC1 (germination vigor factor, contribution 54.60%-58.13%) included vigor index (VI), germination index (GI), and germination rate (GR), while PC2 (biomass factor, contribution 25.21%-27.96%) included fresh weight (FW), dry weight (DW), and shoot length (SL). A comprehensive salt tolerance score (D value) was calculated for each accession using membership function analysis. Cluster analysis grouped the 160 accessions into five categories: highly tolerant (HT), tolerant (RT), moderately tolerant (MT), sensitive (SS), and highly sensitive (HS). Fourteen accessions with high tolerance were identified across all four salt types. Stepwise regression analysis was used to construct optimal linear prediction models. Under NaCl, Na₂SO₄, and NaHCO₃ stress, VI, GI, FW, SL, and GR were significantly correlated with the D value (R² = 0.994-0.999, P < 0.01), while under Na₂CO₃ stress, GI, FW, SL, and RL were significantly correlated (R² = 0.998, P < 0.01), suggesting these traits can serve as reliable salt tolerance indicators. Among them, VI demonstrated greater discriminatory power than the traditional GR, making it a promising comprehensive physiological index. These findings provide a phenotypic foundation for identifying salt-tolerant buckwheat germplasm and support future genome-wide association studies (GWAS) to uncover quantitative trait loci (QTLs) and genes involved in salt tolerance.

Key words: buckwheat, germination, salt tolerance evaluation, principal component analysis, cluster analysis, stepwise regression analysis

黄丽霞, 张卫卫, 甄一越, 王秋宝, 田洪岭, 李国栋, 刘龙龙, 张丽君. 盐胁迫下苦荞萌发期耐盐碱性评价及种质筛选[J]. 作物学报, 2026, 52(2): 459-479.

Huang Li-Xia, Zhang Wei-Wei, Zhen Yi-Yue, Wang Qiu-Bao, Tian Hong-Ling, Li Guo-Dong, Liu Long-Long, Zhang Li-Jun. Evaluation of salinity tolerance and germplasm screening of buckwheat during germination under salt stress[J]. Acta Agronomica Sinica, 2026, 52(2): 459-479.

导出引用管理器 EndNote|Reference Manager|ProCite|BibTeX|RefWorks

链接本文: https://zwxb.chinacrops.org/CN/10.3724/SP.J.1006.2026.51066

https://zwxb.chinacrops.org/CN/Y2026/V52/I2/459

图/表 19

附表1

供试苦荞种质资源"

编号 Number	种质名称 Germplasm name	种质来源 Germplasm origin	编号 Number	种质名称 Germplasm name	种质来源 Germplasm origin	编号 Number	种质名称 Germplasm name	种质来源 Germplasm origin
KQ1	汾西苦荞 Fenxi buckwheat	中国山西汾西 Fenxi, Shanxi, China	KQ55	园籽荞 Garden seed buckwheat	中国云南永胜 Yongsheng, Yunnan, China	KQ109	苦荞麦 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃舟曲 Zhouqu, Gansu, China
KQ2	汾西苦荞 Fenxi buckwheat	中国山西汾西 Fenxi, Shanxi, China	KQ56	苦荞麦 Tartary buckwheat	中国青海互助 Huzhu, Qinghai, China	KQ110	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西略阳 Lueyang, Shaanxi, China
KQ3	38849	中国山西太原 Taiyuan, Shanxi, China	KQ57	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国青海循化 Xunhua, Qinghai, China	KQ111	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁强 Ningqiang, Shaanxi, China
KQ4	中阳苦荞 Zhongyang buckwheat	中国山西中阳 Zhongyang, Shanxi, China	KQ58	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃积石山 Jishishan, Gansu, China	KQ112	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国西藏林芝 Nyingchi, Xizang, China
KQ5	左权苦荞 Zuoquan buckwheat	中国山西左权 Zuoquan, Shanxi, China	KQ59	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃靖远 Jingyuan, Gansu, China	KQ113	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西佛坪 Foping, Shaanxi, China
KQ6	中阳苦荞 Zhongyang buckwheat	中国山西中阳 Zhongyang, Shanxi, China	KQ60	冀苦2号 Jiku 2	中国山西翼城 Yicheng, Shanxi, China	KQ114	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西安康 Ankang, Shaanxi, China
KQ7	创新材料 Innovative materials	中国山西太原 Taiyuan, Shanxi, China	KQ61	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃积石山 Jishishan, Gansu, China	KQ115	黑小荞 Black buckwheat	中国甘肃成县 Chengxian, Gansu, China
KQ8	左权苦荞 Zuoquan buckwheat	中国山西左权 Zuoquan, Shanxi, China	KQ62	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国青海西宁 Xining, Qinghai, China	KQ116	小荞 Xiaoqiao	中国甘肃成县 Chengxian, Gansu, China
KQ9	左权苦荞 Zuoquan buckwheat	中国山西左权 Zuoquan, Shanxi, China	KQ63	黑粒苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国西藏吉隆 Gyirong, Xizang, China	KQ117	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃两当 Liangdang, Gansu, China
KQ10	左权苦荞 Zuoquan buckwheat	中国山西左权 Zuoquan, Shanxi, China	KQ64	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国西藏米林 Milin, Xizang, China	KQ118	麻苦荞 Ma tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃两当 Liangdang, Gansu, China
KQ11	汾西苦荞 Fenxi buckwheat	中国山西汾西 Fenxi, Shanxi, China	KQ65	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国陕西定边 Dingbian, Shaanxi, China	KQ119	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃西和 Xihe, Gansu, China
KQ12	汾西苦荞 Fenxi buckwheat	中国山西汾西 Fenxi, Shanxi, China	KQ66	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西西乡 Xixiang, Shaanxi, China	KQ120	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃张川 Zhangchuan Gansu, China
KQ13	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西灵丘 Lingqiu, Shanxi, China	KQ67	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁陕 Ningshaan, Shaanxi, China	KQ121	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国贵州盘县 Panxian, Guizhou, China
KQ14	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西定襄 Dingxiang, Shanxi, China	KQ68	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁陕 Ningshaan, Shaanxi, China	KQ122	贡山苦荞 Gongshan tartary buckwheat	中国云南贡山 Gongshan, Yunnan, China
KQ15	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西定襄 Dingxiang, Shanxi, China	KQ69	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁陕 Ningshaan, Shaanxi, China	KQ123	哈巴苦荞 Haba buckwheat	中国云南中甸 Zhongdian, Yunnan, China
KQ16	五台苦荞 Wutai buckwheat	中国山西五台 Wutai, Shanxi, China	KQ70	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁陕 Ningshaan, Shaanxi, China	KQ124	马街苦荞 Majie buckwheat	中国云南罗平Luoping, Yunnan, China
KQ17	昔阳苦荞 Xiyang buckwheat	中国山西昔阳 Xiyang, Shanxi, China	KQ71	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁陕 Ningshaan, Shaanxi, China	KQ125	圆裸荞 Round naked buckwheat	中国云南开远 Kaiyuan, Yunnan, China
KQ18	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西太谷 Taigu, Shanxi, China	KQ72	苦荞(棕) Tartary buckwheat (brown)	中国陕西宁陕 Ningshaan, Shaanxi, China	KQ126	墨红苦荞 Mohong tartary buckwheat	中国云南墨江 Mojiang, Yunnan, China
KQ19	本地荞 Local buckwheat	中国山西左权 Zuoquan, Shanxi, China	KQ73	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西白河 Baihe, Shaanxi, China	KQ127	小圆籽苦荞 Xiaoyuanzi tartary buckwheat	中国云南永胜 Yongsheng, Yunnan, China
KQ20	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西左权 Zuoquan, Shanxi, China	KQ74	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西安康 Ankang, Shaanxi, China	KQ128	小扁籽苦荞 Small flat seed tartary buckwheat	中国云南永胜 Yongsheng, Yunnan, China
KQ21	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西介休 Jiexiu, Shanxi, China	KQ75	白苦荞 White tartary buckwheat	中国陕西紫阳 Ziyang, Shaanxi, China	KQ129	长咀苦荞 Changju tartary buckwheat	中国云南永胜 Yongsheng, Yunnan, China
KQ22	荞麦 Buckwheat	中国山西壶关 Huguan, Shanxi, China	KQ76	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西平利 Pingli, Shaanxi, China	KQ130	白杆荞 White stem buckwheat	中国云南永善 Yongshan, Yunnan, China
KQ23	武乡苦荞 Wuxiang buckwheat	中国山西武乡 Wuxiang, Shanxi, China	KQ77	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西兰皋 Langao, Shaanxi, China	KQ131	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国西藏波密 Bomi, Xizang, China
KQ24	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西沁县 Qinxian, Shanxi, China	KQ78	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西兰皋 Langao, Shaanxi, China	KQ132	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国西藏吉隆 Gyirong, Xizang, China
KQ25	霍县苦荞 Huoxian buckwheat	中国山西霍县 Huoxian, Shanxi, China	KQ79	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西兰皋 Langao, Shaanxi, China	KQ133	87-23	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ26	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国内蒙古克什克 Keshike, Inner Mongolia, China	KQ80	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西兰皋 Langao, Shaanxi, China	KQ134	87-24	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ27	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国山西沁县 Qinxian, Shanxi, China	KQ81	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西兰皋 Langao, Shaanxi, China	KQ135	87-26	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ28	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国陕西定边 Dingbian, Shaanxi, China	KQ82	小金黄 Little golden	中国陕西洛南 Luonan, Shaanxi, China	KQ136	87-27	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ29	苦荞麦 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西太白 Taibai, Shaanxi, China	KQ83	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西丹风 Danfeng, Shaanxi, China	KQ137	87-28	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ30	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西宁强 Ningqiang, Shaanxi, China	KQ84	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西柞水 Zhashui, Shaanxi, China	KQ138	87-34	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ31	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西兰皋 Langao, Shaanxi, China	KQ85	苦荞麦 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃榆中 Yuzhong, Gansu, China	KQ139	87-43	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ32	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西商县 Shangxian, Shaanxi, China	KQ86	绿荞 Green buckwheat	中国甘肃靖远 Jingyuan, Gansu, China	KQ140	87-48	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ33	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国陕西镇安 Zhen’an, Shaanxi, China	KQ87	麻苦荞 Ma Tartary Buckwheat	中国甘肃永清 Yongqing, Gansu, China	KQ141	87-53	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ34	苦小荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃成县 Chengxian, Gansu, China	KQ88	荞麦(麻) Buckwheat (Ma)	中国陕西礼县 Lixian, Shaanxi, China	KQ142	87-64	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ35	荞麦 Buckwheat	中国甘肃礼县 Lixian, Gansu, China	KQ89	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国青海民和 Minhe, Qinghai, China	KQ143	87-66	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ36	麻绿荞 Malyuqiao	中国甘肃安县 Anxian, Gansu, China	KQ90	冷饭团 Kadsura coccinea	中国贵州威宁 Weining, Guizhou, China	KQ144	87-73	尼泊尔 Nepal
KQ37	小荞 Xiaoqiao	中国甘肃漳县 Zhangxian, Gansu, China	KQ91	二白苦荞 Erbai tartary buckwheat	中国贵州威宁 Weining, Guizhou, China	KQ145	88-27	日本 Japan
KQ38	小荞 Xiaoqiao	中国甘肃武山 Wushan, Gansu, China	KQ92	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国贵州大方 Dafang, Guizhou, China	KQ146	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃选部 Xuanbu, Gansu, China
KQ39	白绿荞 White green buckwheat	中国甘肃谷县 Guxian, Gansu, China	KQ93	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国贵州文枝 Wenzhi, Guizhou, China	KQ147	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃定西 Dingxi, Gansu, China
KQ40	黑绿荞 Black green buckwheat	中国甘肃谷县 Guxian, Gansu, China	KQ94	洛河苦荞 Luohe tartary buckwheat	中国云南玉溪 Yuxi, Yunnan, China	KQ148	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃华亭 Huating, Gansu, China
KQ41	小荞 Xiaoqiao	中国甘肃天水 Tianshui, Gansu, China	KQ95	大扁籽苦荞 Large flat seed tartary buckwheat	中国云南永胜 Yongsheng, Yunnan, China	KQ149	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃崇信 Chongxin, Gansu, China
KQ42	小荞 Xiaoqiao	中国甘肃天水 Tianshui, Gansu, China	KQ96	88--18	日本 Japan	KQ150	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃平凉 Pingliang, Gansu, China
KQ43	麻苦荞 Ma tartary Buckwheat	中国甘肃静宁 Jingning, Gansu, China	KQ97	荞麦 Buckwheat	中国青海贵德 Guide, Qinghai, China	KQ151	灰苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国青海循化 Xunhua, Qinghai, China
KQ44	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃华亭 Huating, Gansu, China	KQ98	威黑II-2 Weihei II-2	中国贵州威宁 Weining, Guizhou, China	KQ152	荞麦 Buckwheat	中国青海乐都 Ledu, Qinghai, China
KQ45	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃庄浪 Zhuanglang, Gansu, China	KQ99	87-19	尼泊尔 Nepal	KQ153	荞麦 Buckwheat	中国青海互助 Huzhu, Qinghai, China
KQ46	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃宁县 Ningxian, Gansu, China	KQ100	88-14	日本 Japan	KQ154	苦荞(长) Tartary buckwheat (long)	中国青海互助 Huzhu, Qinghai, China
KQ47	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃正宁 Zhengning, Gansu, China	KQ101	湖南1-2 Hunan 1-2	中国湖南 Hunan, China	KQ155	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国安徽太湖 Taihu, Anhui, China
KQ48	苦荞麦 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃合水 Heshui, Gansu, China	KQ102	苦荞麦 Tartary buckwheat	中国甘肃西峰 Xifeng, Gansu, China	KQ156	小苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国四川会理 Huili, Sichuan, China
KQ49	白苦荞 White tartary buckwheat	中国青海民和 Minhe, Qinghai, China	KQ103	甘荞1号 Ganqiao 1	中国甘肃平凉 Pingliang, Gansu, China	KQ157	90--4	中国贵州威宁 Weining, Guizhou, China
KQ50	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国青海民和 Minhe, Qinghai, China	KQ104	荞麦 Buckwheat	中国青海乐都 Ledu, Qinghai, China	KQ158	彭泽苦荞 Pengze tartary buckwheat	中国江西彭泽 Pengze, Jiangxi, China
KQ51	大白苦荞 Daba tartary buckwheat	中国贵州威宁 Weining, Guizhou, China	KQ105	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国西藏亚东 Yadong, Xizang, China	KQ159	晋荞麦4号 Jin Buckwheat 4	中国山西交口 Jiaokou, Shanxi, China
KQ52	黑苦荞 Black tartary buckwheat	中国贵州赫章 Hezhang, Guizhou, China	KQ106	中圆籽荞 Zhongyuan seed buckwheat	中国云南腾冲 Tengchong, Yunnan, China	KQ160	20140016	中国山西太原 Taiyuan, Shanxi, China
KQ53	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国贵州赫章 Hezhang, Guizhou, China	KQ107	小米荞 Xiaomi buckwheat	中国云南腾冲 Tengchong, Yunnan, China
KQ54	苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国贵州赫章 Hezhang, Guizhou, China	KQ108	细苦荞 Tartary buckwheat	中国云南腾冲 Tengchong, Yunnan, China

附表1

表1

表2

表3

中性盐和碱性盐胁迫下苦荞萌发期各指标的变化"

指标 Index	参数 Parameter	对照 Control	NaCl胁迫 NaCl stress	较对照变化 Comparison	Na₂SO₄ 胁迫 Na₂SO₄ stress	较对照变化 Comparison	NaHCO₃ 胁迫 NaHCO₃ stress	较对照变化 Comparison	Na₂CO₃ 胁迫 Na₂CO₃ stress	较对照变化 Comparison
根长 RL (cm)	最大值Max.	13.54	11.69	-1.85	11.41	-2.13	10.46	-3.08	10.03	-3.51
	最小值Min.	5.38	1.25	-4.13	1.22	-4.16	1.29	-4.09	0.98	-4.40
	均值Average	8.58	6.34	-2.24	6.03	-2.55	5.80	-2.78	5.50	-3.08
	标准差SE	1.67	2.49	0.83	2.48	0.81	2.44	0.77	2.43	0.76
	变异系数CV (%)	19.41	39.30	19.89	41.12	21.71	42.13	22.72	44.14	24.73
芽长 SL (cm)	最大值Max.	7.12	6.83	-0.29	6.94	-0.18	7.77	0.65	6.86	-0.26
	最小值Min.	1.63	0.71	-0.92	0.76	-0.87	0.75	-0.88	0.67	-0.96
	均值Average	3.77	2.99	-0.78	2.84	-0.93	2.88	-0.89	2.64	-1.13
	标准差SE	1.18	1.30	0.12	1.27	0.09	1.35	0.17	1.26	0.08
	变异系数CV (%)	31.39	43.48	12.09	44.57	13.18	46.83	15.44	47.89	16.50
鲜重 FW (g)	最大值Max.	0.5440	0.4650	-0.0790	0.4512	-0.0928	0.4200	-0.1240	0.4152	-0.1288
	最小值Min.	0.1690	0.0510	-0.1180	0.0313	-0.1377	0.0400	-0.1290	0.0324	-0.1366
	均值Average	0.3210	0.2457	-0.0753	0.2308	-0.0902	0.2205	-0.1005	0.2061	-0.1149
	标准差SE	0.0752	0.0586	-0.0166	0.1026	0.0274	0.1008	0.0256	0.1004	0.0252
	变异系数CV (%)	23.42	41.66	18.24	44.44	21.02	45.72	22.30	48.70	25.28
干重 DW (g)	最大值Max.	0.0270	0.0250	-0.0020	0.0239	-0.0031	0.0200	-0.0070	0.0279	0.0009
	最小值Min.	0.0120	0.0040	-0.0080	0.0029	-0.0091	0.0033	-0.0087	0.0026	-0.0094
	均值Average	0.0175	0.0141	-0.0034	0.0133	-0.0042	0.0130	-0.0045	0.0124	-0.0051
	标准差SE	0.0003	0.0003	0.0000	0.0044	0.0041	0.0044	0.0041	0.0044	0.0041
	变异系数CV (%)	18.46	31.54	13.08	33.04	14.58	33.62	15.16	35.58	17.12
发芽势GP (%)	最大值Max.	0.97	1.00	0.03	1.00	0.03	1.00	0.03	0.98	0.01
	最小值Min.	0.67	0.56	-0.11	0.52	-0.15	0.49	-0.18	0.42	-0.25
	均值Average	0.85	0.85	0.00	0.82	-0.03	0.79	-0.06	0.76	-0.09
	标准差SE	0.05	0.10	0.05	0.11	0.06	0.12	0.07	0.12	0.07
	变异系数CV (%)	6.01	12.11	6.10	13.23	7.22	14.70	8.69	16.12	10.11
发芽率GR (%)	最大值Max.	0.99	1.00	0.01	10.99	10.00	1.00	0.01	1.00	0.01
	最小值Min.	0.80	0.62	-0.18	0.56	-0.24	0.52	-0.28	0.41	-0.39
	均值Average	0.92	0.90	-0.02	0.88	-0.04	0.84	-0.08	0.81	-0.11
发芽率GR (%)	标准差SE	0.03	0.08	0.05	0.25	0.22	0.11	0.08	0.12	0.09
发芽率GR (%)	变异系数CV (%)	3.50	9.13	5.63	28.45	24.95	12.77	9.27	14.54	11.04
发芽指数 GI	最大值Max.	13.95	14.75	0.80	14.72	0.77	14.62	0.67	14.23	0.28
	最小值Min.	10.10	8.31	-1.79	2.53	-7.57	7.08	-3.02	2.79	-7.31
	均值Average	12.51	12.41	-0.10	11.97	-0.54	11.52	-0.99	11.06	-1.45
	标准差SE	0.63	1.40	0.77	1.51	0.88	1.62	0.99	1.74	1.11
	变异系数CV (%)	5.01	11.26	6.25	12.65	7.64	14.08	9.07	15.69	10.68
活力指数 VI	最大值Max.	174.54	165.82	-8.72	150.94	-23.60	144.45	-30.09	135.56	-38.98
	最小值Min.	66.92	12.58	-54.34	10.69	-56.23	10.52	-56.40	8.64	-58.28
	均值Average	107.15	81.35	-25.80	75.04	-32.11	69.92	-37.23	64.15	-43.00
	标准差SE	20.77	38.04	17.27	37.17	16.40	36.24	15.47	35.31	14.54
	变异系数CV (%)	19.38	46.76	27.38	49.53	30.15	51.83	32.45	55.04	35.66
含水量MC	最大值Max.	0.9520	0.9523	0.0003	0.9532	0.0012	0.9532	0.0012	0.9531	0.0011
	最小值Min.	0.9090	0.9023	-0.0067	0.8725	-0.0365	0.8661	-0.0429	0.8509	-0.0581
	均值Average	0.9444	0.9384	-0.0060	0.9365	-0.0079	0.9351	-0.0093	0.9329	-0.0115
	标准差SE	0.0082	0.0120	0.0038	0.0163	0.0081	0.0176	0.0094	0.0196	0.0114
	变异系数CV (%)	0.87	1.54	0.67	1.75	0.88	1.88	1.01	2.10	1.23

表3

图1

表4

表5

附表2

NaCl盐胁迫下苦荞种质萌发期的综合指标、隶属函数值、权重、D值和排序"

编号 Number	综合指标值 Value of composite indicator		隶属函数值 value of the affiliation function		D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
编号 Number	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
KQ1	2.74	0.60	1.82	0.20	2.02	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	131
KQ2	4.62	0.99	3.06	0.33	3.39	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	29
KQ3	3.79	1.25	2.51	0.42	2.93	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	67
KQ4	2.80	1.58	1.85	0.53	2.38	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	110
KQ5	4.73	0.96	3.13	0.32	3.45	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	22
KQ6	3.58	-0.21	2.37	-0.07	2.30	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	116
KQ7	3.30	1.36	2.18	0.46	2.64	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	91
KQ8	2.27	-0.21	1.50	-0.07	1.43	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	152
KQ9	4.99	1.21	3.30	0.41	3.71	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	10
KQ10	1.34	1.08	0.89	0.36	1.25	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	154
KQ11	4.58	0.83	3.03	0.28	3.31	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	34
KQ12	4.21	1.11	2.79	0.37	3.16	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	52
KQ13	3.48	1.30	2.30	0.44	2.74	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	80
KQ14	3.87	1.11	2.56	0.38	2.94	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	66
KQ15	3.82	1.28	2.53	0.43	2.96	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	62
KQ16	3.17	-0.79	2.10	-0.27	1.83	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	143
KQ17	4.25	1.34	2.81	0.45	3.26	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	38
KQ18	4.00	0.19	2.65	0.06	2.71	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	83
KQ19	3.19	1.65	2.11	0.56	2.67	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	85
KQ20	4.20	-0.34	2.78	-0.12	2.66	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	87
KQ21	4.11	1.11	2.72	0.38	3.09	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	56
KQ22	2.23	0.90	1.48	0.30	1.78	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	146
KQ23	2.14	1.17	1.41	0.40	1.81	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	145
KQ24	4.37	0.96	2.89	0.33	3.22	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	45
KQ25	2.28	1.37	1.51	0.46	1.97	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	136
KQ26	5.16	0.98	3.42	0.33	3.75	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	9
KQ27	2.58	1.51	1.71	0.51	2.22	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	119
KQ28	3.12	1.73	2.06	0.58	2.65	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	88
KQ29	5.47	1.01	3.62	0.34	3.96	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	4
KQ30	5.04	0.36	3.33	0.12	3.46	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	20
KQ31	3.71	1.38	2.46	0.47	2.92	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	68
KQ32	3.60	1.73	2.38	0.58	2.96	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	61
KQ33	3.52	1.38	2.33	0.47	2.80	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	77
KQ34	3.34	0.67	2.21	0.23	2.43	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	107
KQ35	3.16	1.24	2.09	0.42	2.51	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	100
KQ36	4.56	1.14	3.02	0.38	3.40	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	27
KQ37	2.88	1.40	1.91	0.47	2.38	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	112
KQ38	3.24	-0.17	2.15	-0.06	2.09	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	130
KQ39	5.30	-0.12	3.50	-0.04	3.46	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	19
KQ40	3.23	0.73	2.14	0.25	2.38	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	111
KQ41	3.27	1.26	2.16	0.43	2.59	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	94
KQ42	3.81	0.83	2.52	0.28	2.80	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	76
KQ43	2.97	0.46	1.97	0.16	2.12	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	125
KQ44	4.26	0.88	2.82	0.30	3.11	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	55
KQ45	5.79	0.55	3.83	0.19	4.02	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	2
KQ46	4.97	0.18	3.29	0.06	3.35	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	33
KQ47	2.57	0.22	1.70	0.08	1.78	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	147
KQ48	3.65	0.14	2.41	0.05	2.46	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	104
KQ49	3.22	1.42	2.13	0.48	2.61	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	92
KQ50	4.18	0.68	2.76	0.23	2.99	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	58
KQ51	1.31	0.22	0.86	0.08	0.94	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	158
KQ52	2.65	0.76	1.75	0.26	2.01	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	132
KQ53	1.69	0.15	1.12	0.05	1.17	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	157
KQ54	4.25	1.03	2.81	0.35	3.16	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	51
KQ55	3.00	0.98	1.98	0.33	2.31	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	114
KQ56	4.03	1.12	2.67	0.38	3.05	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	57
KQ57	4.65	0.25	3.08	0.09	3.16	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	50
KQ58	4.10	1.56	2.71	0.53	3.24	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	41
KQ59	4.33	0.26	2.87	0.09	2.96	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	64
KQ60	2.96	1.03	1.96	0.35	2.31	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	115
KQ61	3.58	1.59	2.37	0.54	2.91	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	72
KQ62	5.03	0.90	3.33	0.31	3.63	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	14
KQ63	2.89	1.43	1.91	0.48	2.39	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	108
KQ64	4.65	0.85	3.08	0.29	3.36	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	31
KQ65	3.13	-0.26	2.07	-0.09	1.98	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	134
KQ66	5.33	0.89	3.53	0.30	3.83	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	7
KQ67	3.78	1.21	2.50	0.41	2.91	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	70
KQ68	3.05	1.52	2.02	0.52	2.53	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	97
KQ69	5.04	0.95	3.33	0.32	3.65	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	13
KQ70	4.33	1.26	2.87	0.43	3.29	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	36
KQ71	3.34	1.48	2.21	0.50	2.71	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	82
KQ72	5.05	0.58	3.34	0.20	3.54	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	17
KQ73	5.57	-0.05	3.69	-0.02	3.67	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	11
KQ74	4.58	0.75	3.03	0.25	3.28	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	37
KQ75	4.70	0.88	3.11	0.30	3.41	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	26
KQ76	3.19	-0.02	2.11	-0.01	2.10	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	127
KQ77	3.13	1.29	2.07	0.44	2.51	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	101
KQ78	3.47	1.29	2.30	0.44	2.73	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	81
KQ79	3.28	1.23	2.17	0.42	2.59	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	95
KQ80	3.18	0.22	2.10	0.07	2.18	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	123
KQ81	2.10	0.72	1.39	0.24	1.63	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	150
KQ82	3.73	1.20	2.47	0.40	2.87	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	75
KQ83	3.56	0.92	2.35	0.31	2.66	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	86
KQ84	3.10	1.27	2.05	0.43	2.48	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	102
KQ85	3.44	1.08	2.28	0.37	2.64	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	90
KQ86	2.26	1.09	1.49	0.37	1.86	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	141
KQ87	2.64	1.38	1.75	0.47	2.21	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	120
KQ88	3.15	-0.39	2.08	-0.13	1.95	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	138
KQ89	2.89	0.20	1.91	0.07	1.98	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	135
KQ90	3.80	0.30	2.51	0.10	2.61	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	93
KQ91	2.66	1.42	1.76	0.48	2.24	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	117
KQ92	5.04	0.26	3.33	0.09	3.42	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	24
KQ93	2.73	1.15	1.80	0.39	2.19	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	122
KQ94	2.89	0.75	1.91	0.25	2.17	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	124
KQ95	4.30	1.12	2.85	0.38	3.22	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	43
KQ96	2.93	1.47	1.94	0.50	2.44	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	105
KQ97	1.72	0.19	1.14	0.06	1.20	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	156
KQ98	3.78	0.78	2.50	0.26	2.77	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	79
KQ99	4.62	1.14	3.06	0.38	3.44	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	23
KQ100	2.90	-0.28	1.92	-0.10	1.82	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	144
KQ101	2.58	1.17	1.71	0.39	2.10	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	128
KQ102	4.71	0.57	3.12	0.19	3.31	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	35
KQ103	2.89	1.79	1.91	0.61	2.52	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	99
KQ104	4.73	0.95	3.13	0.32	3.45	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	21
KQ105	1.06	-0.41	0.70	-0.14	0.57	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	160
KQ106	3.42	0.65	2.26	0.22	2.48	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	103
KQ107	2.58	0.41	1.71	0.14	1.85	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	142
KQ108	2.47	1.79	1.64	0.60	2.24	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	118
KQ109	2.54	0.95	1.68	0.32	2.00	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	133
KQ110	5.47	0.70	3.62	0.24	3.86	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	6
KQ111	4.13	0.51	2.74	0.17	2.91	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	71
KQ112	4.34	0.90	2.87	0.30	3.17	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	47
KQ113	2.19	0.65	1.45	0.22	1.67	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	149
KQ114	5.29	0.46	3.50	0.15	3.66	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	12
KQ115	3.04	1.95	2.01	0.66	2.67	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	84
KQ116	2.37	0.86	1.57	0.29	1.86	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	140
KQ117	4.19	1.33	2.77	0.45	3.23	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	42
KQ118	3.55	1.24	2.35	0.42	2.77	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	78
KQ119	4.00	0.74	2.65	0.25	2.90	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	73
KQ120	2.29	0.70	1.51	0.24	1.75	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	148
KQ121	3.33	0.96	2.21	0.32	2.53	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	98
KQ122	4.58	0.45	3.03	0.15	3.18	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	46
KQ123	2.75	0.83	1.82	0.28	2.10	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	129
KQ124	5.64	0.45	3.74	0.15	3.89	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	5
KQ125	4.18	0.55	2.77	0.19	2.96	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	63
KQ126	5.39	0.63	3.57	0.21	3.78	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	8
KQ127	1.47	-0.36	0.97	-0.12	0.85	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	159
KQ128	4.31	0.29	2.86	0.10	2.95	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	65
KQ129	2.81	1.56	1.86	0.53	2.39	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	109
KQ130	4.53	0.52	3.00	0.18	3.17	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	49
KQ131	4.79	0.69	3.17	0.23	3.40	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	28
KQ132	6.01	0.13	3.98	0.04	4.02	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	1
KQ133	4.76	0.27	3.15	0.09	3.24	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	40
KQ134	5.77	0.48	3.82	0.16	3.98	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	3
KQ135	3.34	1.00	2.21	0.34	2.55	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	96
KQ136	2.38	1.09	1.57	0.37	1.94	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	139
KQ137	1.82	0.66	1.20	0.22	1.43	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	153
KQ138	4.32	1.06	2.86	0.36	3.22	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	44
KQ139	2.31	1.27	1.53	0.43	1.96	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	137
KQ140	2.85	1.28	1.88	0.43	2.32	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	113
KQ141	4.78	0.56	3.17	0.19	3.35	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	32
KQ142	4.20	1.16	2.78	0.39	3.17	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	48
KQ143	3.91	1.15	2.59	0.39	2.98	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	60
KQ144	1.76	0.16	1.17	0.06	1.22	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	155
KQ145	2.02	0.65	1.34	0.22	1.56	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	151
KQ146	4.00	1.01	2.64	0.34	2.99	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	59
KQ147	3.09	1.16	2.05	0.39	2.44	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	106
KQ148	4.31	0.20	2.85	0.07	2.92	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	69
KQ149	5.00	0.86	3.31	0.29	3.60	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	16
KQ150	4.66	0.96	3.09	0.32	3.41	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	25
KQ151	3.92	0.84	2.59	0.29	2.88	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	74
KQ152	4.09	1.29	2.71	0.44	3.14	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	53
KQ153	4.47	1.20	2.96	0.41	3.36	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	30
KQ154	3.49	0.99	2.31	0.33	2.65	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	89
KQ155	2.93	0.80	1.94	0.27	2.21	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	121
KQ156	3.06	0.25	2.03	0.08	2.11	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	126
KQ157	4.89	0.75	3.23	0.25	3.49	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	18
KQ158	4.41	0.98	2.92	0.33	3.25	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	39
KQ159	4.53	0.38	3.00	0.13	3.13	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	54
KQ160	5.15	0.65	3.41	0.22	3.63	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	15
权重W_i				0.66	0.34

附表2

附表3

Na2SO4胁迫下苦荞种质萌发的综合指标、隶属函数、权重、D值和排序"

编号 Number	综合指标值 Value of composite indicator		隶属函数值 Value of the affiliation function		D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
编号 Number	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
KQ1	3.29	0.60	2.26	0.19	2.45	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	139
KQ2	4.83	0.99	3.31	0.31	3.62	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	30
KQ3	4.36	1.25	2.99	0.39	3.38	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	58
KQ4	3.33	1.58	2.29	0.50	2.78	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	115
KQ5	4.85	0.96	3.33	0.30	3.63	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	26
KQ6	4.02	-0.21	2.75	-0.07	2.69	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	122
KQ7	3.82	1.36	2.62	0.43	3.04	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	91
KQ8	2.86	-0.21	1.96	-0.07	1.89	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	156
KQ9	5.14	1.21	3.52	0.38	3.90	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	7
KQ10	2.34	1.08	1.60	0.34	1.94	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	155
KQ11	4.80	0.83	3.29	0.26	3.55	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	40
KQ12	4.60	1.11	3.15	0.35	3.50	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	44
KQ13	4.00	1.30	2.74	0.41	3.15	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	83
KQ14	4.31	1.11	2.96	0.35	3.31	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	67
KQ15	4.32	1.28	2.96	0.40	3.37	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	59
KQ16	3.94	-0.79	2.70	-0.25	2.45	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	138
KQ17	4.52	1.34	3.10	0.42	3.52	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	43
KQ18	4.32	0.19	2.96	0.06	3.02	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	94
KQ19	3.79	1.65	2.60	0.52	3.12	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	85
KQ20	4.35	-0.34	2.98	-0.11	2.87	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	110
KQ21	4.50	1.11	3.09	0.35	3.44	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	55
KQ22	3.04	0.90	2.08	0.28	2.36	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	145
KQ23	2.90	1.17	1.98	0.37	2.35	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	146
KQ24	4.62	0.96	3.17	0.30	3.47	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	48
KQ25	3.12	1.37	2.14	0.43	2.57	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	132
KQ26	5.37	0.98	3.68	0.31	3.99	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	4
KQ27	3.29	1.51	2.26	0.48	2.73	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	118
KQ28	3.79	1.73	2.60	0.54	3.14	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	84
KQ29	5.48	1.01	3.76	0.32	4.07	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	2
KQ30	5.17	0.36	3.54	0.11	3.66	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	23
KQ31	4.22	1.38	2.90	0.43	3.33	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	62
KQ32	4.12	1.73	2.82	0.54	3.37	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	60
KQ33	4.08	1.38	2.79	0.44	3.23	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	75
KQ34	3.94	0.67	2.70	0.21	2.91	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	105
KQ35	3.78	1.24	2.59	0.39	2.99	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	98
KQ36	4.87	1.14	3.34	0.36	3.70	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	18
KQ37	3.59	1.40	2.46	0.44	2.90	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	109
KQ38	4.07	-0.17	2.79	-0.05	2.74	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	117
KQ39	5.24	-0.12	3.59	-0.04	3.55	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	38
KQ40	3.81	0.73	2.61	0.23	2.84	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	111
KQ41	4.43	1.26	3.04	0.40	3.44	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	54
KQ42	4.16	0.83	2.85	0.26	3.11	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	86
KQ43	3.33	0.46	2.28	0.15	2.43	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	141
KQ44	4.65	0.88	3.19	0.28	3.46	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	50
KQ45	5.69	0.55	3.90	0.17	4.07	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	1
KQ46	5.13	0.18	3.52	0.06	3.57	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	34
KQ47	3.35	0.22	2.30	0.07	2.37	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	143
KQ48	4.17	0.14	2.86	0.04	2.90	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	108
KQ49	3.83	1.42	2.62	0.45	3.07	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	90
KQ50	4.48	0.68	3.07	0.22	3.28	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	70
KQ51	2.35	0.22	1.61	0.07	1.68	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	159
KQ52	3.09	0.76	2.12	0.24	2.35	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	147
KQ53	2.77	0.15	1.90	0.05	1.95	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	154
KQ54	4.54	1.03	3.11	0.32	3.43	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	56
KQ55	3.68	0.98	2.52	0.31	2.83	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	112
KQ56	4.31	1.12	2.96	0.35	3.31	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	65
KQ57	4.91	0.25	3.37	0.08	3.45	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	53
KQ58	4.46	1.56	3.06	0.49	3.55	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	39
KQ59	4.63	0.26	3.18	0.08	3.26	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	73
KQ60	3.44	1.03	2.36	0.32	2.68	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	123
KQ61	4.14	1.59	2.84	0.50	3.34	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	61
KQ62	5.17	0.90	3.54	0.28	3.83	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	13
KQ63	3.66	1.43	2.51	0.45	2.96	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	101
KQ64	4.84	0.85	3.32	0.27	3.59	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	32
KQ65	4.00	-0.26	2.74	-0.08	2.66	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	124
KQ66	5.22	0.89	3.58	0.28	3.86	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	10
KQ67	4.11	1.21	2.82	0.38	3.20	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	78
KQ68	3.83	1.52	2.63	0.48	3.11	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	87
KQ69	5.21	0.95	3.57	0.30	3.87	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	8
KQ70	4.71	1.26	3.23	0.40	3.63	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	27
KQ71	3.95	1.48	2.71	0.47	3.18	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	79
KQ72	5.17	0.58	3.54	0.18	3.72	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	17
KQ73	5.51	-0.05	3.77	-0.01	3.76	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	16
KQ74	4.81	0.75	3.30	0.23	3.53	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	41
KQ75	4.94	0.88	3.38	0.28	3.66	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	22
KQ76	3.82	-0.02	2.62	-0.01	2.61	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	128
KQ77	3.80	1.29	2.61	0.41	3.01	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	95
KQ78	4.13	1.29	2.83	0.41	3.23	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	74
KQ79	3.86	1.23	2.65	0.39	3.03	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	92
KQ80	3.88	0.22	2.66	0.07	2.73	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	119
KQ81	2.90	0.72	1.98	0.23	2.21	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	151
KQ82	4.13	1.20	2.83	0.38	3.20	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	77
KQ83	4.08	0.92	2.79	0.29	3.08	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	89
KQ84	3.72	1.27	2.55	0.40	2.95	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	102
KQ85	4.02	1.08	2.75	0.34	3.09	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	88
KQ86	2.99	1.09	2.05	0.34	2.39	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	142
KQ87	3.45	1.38	2.36	0.43	2.80	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	114
KQ88	3.82	-0.39	2.62	-0.12	2.50	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	135
KQ89	3.73	0.20	2.55	0.06	2.62	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	127
KQ90	4.29	0.30	2.94	0.09	3.03	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	93
KQ91	3.29	1.42	2.26	0.45	2.70	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	121
KQ92	5.16	0.26	3.54	0.08	3.62	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	31
KQ93	3.42	1.15	2.35	0.36	2.71	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	120
KQ94	3.49	0.75	2.39	0.24	2.63	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	126
KQ95	4.52	1.12	3.10	0.35	3.45	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	52
KQ96	3.65	1.47	2.50	0.46	2.96	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	100
KQ97	3.16	0.19	2.16	0.06	2.22	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	150
KQ98	4.27	0.78	2.93	0.25	3.17	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	80
KQ99	4.76	1.14	3.26	0.36	3.62	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	29
KQ100	3.12	-0.28	2.14	-0.09	2.05	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	153
KQ101	3.16	1.17	2.17	0.37	2.53	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	133
KQ102	4.94	0.57	3.39	0.18	3.57	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	35
KQ103	3.48	1.79	2.38	0.56	2.95	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	103
KQ104	4.94	0.95	3.38	0.30	3.68	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	20
KQ105	1.76	-0.41	1.21	-0.13	1.08	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	160
KQ106	4.07	0.65	2.79	0.20	2.99	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	97
KQ107	3.26	0.41	2.24	0.13	2.37	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	144
KQ108	3.21	1.79	2.20	0.56	2.76	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	116
KQ109	3.14	0.95	2.15	0.30	2.45	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	137
KQ110	5.31	0.70	3.64	0.22	3.86	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	9
KQ111	4.56	0.51	3.12	0.16	3.28	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	69
KQ112	4.95	0.90	3.39	0.28	3.68	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	21
KQ113	3.01	0.65	2.06	0.21	2.27	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	149
KQ114	5.35	0.46	3.66	0.14	3.81	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	15
KQ115	3.72	1.95	2.55	0.61	3.16	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	81
KQ116	3.16	0.86	2.16	0.27	2.43	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	140
KQ117	4.58	1.33	3.14	0.42	3.56	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	36
KQ118	4.03	1.24	2.76	0.39	3.15	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	82
KQ119	4.43	0.74	3.04	0.23	3.27	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	72
KQ120	3.26	0.70	2.23	0.22	2.45	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	136
KQ121	3.91	0.96	2.68	0.30	2.98	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	99
KQ122	4.89	0.45	3.35	0.14	3.49	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	45
KQ123	3.42	0.83	2.34	0.26	2.60	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	129
KQ124	5.52	0.45	3.79	0.14	3.93	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	6
KQ125	4.53	0.55	3.11	0.17	3.28	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	71
KQ126	5.29	0.63	3.63	0.20	3.82	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	14
KQ127	2.69	-0.36	1.85	-0.11	1.73	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	158
KQ128	4.70	0.29	3.22	0.09	3.31	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	64
KQ129	3.53	1.56	2.42	0.49	2.91	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	106
KQ130	4.82	0.52	3.30	0.16	3.47	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	49
KQ131	4.97	0.69	3.41	0.22	3.62	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	28
KQ132	5.71	0.13	3.91	0.04	3.95	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	5
KQ133	4.95	0.27	3.39	0.09	3.48	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	47
KQ134	5.63	0.48	3.86	0.15	4.01	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	3
KQ135	3.93	1.00	2.69	0.32	3.01	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	96
KQ136	3.17	1.09	2.18	0.34	2.52	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	134
KQ137	3.09	0.66	2.12	0.21	2.32	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	148
KQ138	4.71	1.06	3.23	0.33	3.56	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	37
KQ139	3.28	1.27	2.25	0.40	2.65	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	125
KQ140	3.52	1.28	2.41	0.40	2.82	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	113
KQ141	5.04	0.56	3.46	0.18	3.63	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	25
KQ142	4.51	1.16	3.09	0.36	3.46	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	51
KQ143	4.29	1.15	2.94	0.36	3.31	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	66
KQ144	2.68	0.16	1.83	0.05	1.89	盐极敏感型Extremely salt-sensitive	157
KQ145	2.83	0.65	1.94	0.20	2.14	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	152
KQ146	4.36	1.01	2.99	0.32	3.30	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	68
KQ147	3.74	1.16	2.57	0.36	2.93	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	104
KQ148	4.76	0.20	3.26	0.06	3.32	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	63
KQ149	5.20	0.86	3.56	0.27	3.84	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	11
KQ150	4.88	0.96	3.35	0.30	3.65	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	24
KQ151	4.32	0.84	2.96	0.27	3.23	较耐盐型Salt-tolerant	76
KQ152	4.50	1.29	3.08	0.41	3.49	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	46
KQ153	4.66	1.20	3.20	0.38	3.57	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	33
KQ154	3.78	0.99	2.59	0.31	2.90	中等耐盐型Moderate salt-tolerant	107
KQ155	3.43	0.80	2.35	0.25	2.60	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	130
KQ156	3.63	0.25	2.49	0.08	2.57	盐敏感型Salt-sensitive	131
KQ157	5.04	0.75	3.45	0.23	3.69	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	19
KQ158	4.69	0.98	3.21	0.31	3.52	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	42
KQ159	4.78	0.38	3.28	0.12	3.40	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	57
KQ160	5.30	0.65	3.63	0.20	3.83	高耐盐型High salt-tolerant	12
权重Wi			0.69	0.31

附表3

附表4

NaHCO3胁迫下苦荞种质萌发期的综合指标、隶属函数值、权重、D值和排序"

编号 Number	综合指标值 Value of composite indicator		隶属函数值 Value of the affiliation function		D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
编号 Number	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
KQ1	2.88	0.36	1.91	0.12	2.03	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		130
KQ2	4.96	0.67	3.29	0.23	3.52	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		16
KQ3	4.11	0.94	2.73	0.32	3.04	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		60
KQ4	3.01	1.22	2.00	0.41	2.41	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		112
KQ5	4.79	0.58	3.18	0.19	3.37	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		28
KQ6	3.64	-0.59	2.41	-0.20	2.21	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		123
KQ7	3.51	1.12	2.33	0.38	2.70	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		87
KQ8	1.75	-0.09	1.16	-0.03	1.13	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		154
KQ9	5.23	0.84	3.47	0.28	3.76	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		7
KQ10	1.26	0.61	0.84	0.21	1.04	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		156
KQ11	4.62	0.43	3.06	0.15	3.21	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		45
KQ12	4.43	0.72	2.94	0.24	3.18	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		47
KQ13	3.71	1.03	2.46	0.35	2.81	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		80
KQ14	4.01	0.81	2.66	0.27	2.93	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		67
KQ15	4.09	0.93	2.71	0.31	3.02	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		61
KQ16	3.16	-1.39	2.10	-0.47	1.63	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		145
KQ17	4.51	1.06	2.99	0.36	3.35	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		31
KQ18	4.08	-0.32	2.70	-0.11	2.60	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		95
KQ19	3.51	1.41	2.33	0.47	2.80	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		81
KQ20	4.05	-0.85	2.69	-0.28	2.41	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		113
KQ21	4.27	0.81	2.83	0.27	3.11	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		54
KQ22	3.05	0.23	2.02	0.08	2.10	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		128
KQ23	2.75	0.60	1.82	0.20	2.02	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		131
KQ24	4.58	0.65	3.04	0.22	3.26	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		44
KQ25	2.58	1.26	1.71	0.42	2.14	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		125
KQ26	5.49	0.56	3.64	0.19	3.83	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		5
KQ27	2.79	1.37	1.85	0.46	2.31	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		116
KQ28	3.46	1.49	2.30	0.50	2.80	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		82
KQ29	5.69	0.63	3.78	0.21	3.99	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		1
KQ30	5.17	-0.01	3.43	0.00	3.43	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		20
KQ31	4.00	1.10	2.65	0.37	3.02	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		62
KQ32	4.43	1.13	2.94	0.38	3.32	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		36
KQ33	3.86	1.16	2.56	0.39	2.95	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		63
KQ34	3.63	0.53	2.41	0.18	2.59	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		96
KQ35	3.34	1.05	2.22	0.35	2.57	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		102
KQ36	4.83	0.79	3.20	0.26	3.47	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		19
KQ37	3.08	1.09	2.04	0.37	2.41	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		111
KQ38	3.29	-0.59	2.18	-0.20	1.98	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		135
KQ39	5.33	-0.62	3.54	-0.21	3.33	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		35
KQ40	3.14	0.11	2.08	0.04	2.12	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		127
KQ41	3.54	0.96	2.35	0.32	2.67	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		91
KQ42	4.21	0.30	2.80	0.10	2.90	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		76
KQ43	2.26	0.28	1.50	0.09	1.60	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		146
KQ44	4.49	0.55	2.98	0.19	3.17	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		49
KQ45	5.88	0.15	3.90	0.05	3.95	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		2
KQ46	5.05	-0.22	3.35	-0.07	3.28	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		40
KQ47	2.42	-0.10	1.61	-0.03	1.57	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		147
KQ48	2.81	0.16	1.86	0.06	1.92	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		137
KQ49	3.55	1.18	2.36	0.40	2.75	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		84
KQ50	4.19	0.37	2.78	0.12	2.90	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		74
KQ51	1.81	-0.26	1.20	-0.09	1.12	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		155
KQ52	3.25	0.31	2.15	0.11	2.26	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		118
KQ53	2.09	-0.19	1.38	-0.07	1.32	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		151
KQ54	4.52	0.82	3.00	0.27	3.27	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		42
KQ55	3.35	1.20	2.23	0.40	2.63	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		92
KQ56	4.02	0.82	2.67	0.28	2.94	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		65
KQ57	4.69	-0.02	3.11	-0.01	3.11	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		55
KQ58	4.32	1.23	2.87	0.41	3.28	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		39
KQ59	4.36	0.01	2.90	0.00	2.90	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		75
KQ60	3.27	0.33	2.17	0.11	2.28	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		117
KQ61	3.81	1.17	2.53	0.39	2.92	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		71
KQ62	5.14	0.51	3.41	0.17	3.58	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		14
KQ63	3.51	0.88	2.33	0.30	2.62	中等耐碱型Extremely alkali-sensitive		93
KQ64	4.84	0.54	3.21	0.18	3.39	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		24
KQ65	3.34	-0.66	2.22	-0.22	2.00	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		133
KQ66	5.40	0.53	3.59	0.18	3.76	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		6
KQ67	3.92	0.94	2.60	0.32	2.92	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		70
KQ68	3.35	1.07	2.22	0.36	2.58	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		97
KQ69	5.29	0.61	3.51	0.20	3.71	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		8
KQ70	4.64	0.90	3.08	0.30	3.38	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		26
KQ71	3.52	1.20	2.34	0.40	2.74	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		85
KQ72	5.18	0.23	3.43	0.08	3.51	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		17
KQ73	5.52	-0.50	3.66	-0.17	3.49	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		18
KQ74	4.64	0.36	3.08	0.12	3.20	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		46
KQ75	4.79	0.50	3.18	0.17	3.35	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		30
KQ76	3.12	-0.46	2.07	-0.15	1.91	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		138
KQ77	3.33	0.99	2.21	0.33	2.55	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		103
KQ78	3.94	1.00	2.61	0.34	2.95	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		64
KQ79	3.53	0.98	2.34	0.33	2.67	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		90
KQ80	2.65	0.00	1.76	0.00	1.76	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		143
KQ81	1.78	0.51	1.18	0.17	1.36	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		150
KQ82	3.94	0.93	2.61	0.31	2.93	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		69
KQ83	3.57	0.60	2.37	0.20	2.57	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		101
KQ84	3.40	1.03	2.26	0.35	2.60	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		94
KQ85	3.65	0.78	2.42	0.26	2.69	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		88
KQ86	2.26	1.11	1.50	0.37	1.88	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		140
KQ87	3.36	0.94	2.23	0.32	2.54	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		105
KQ88	3.16	-0.58	2.10	-0.20	1.90	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		139
KQ89	2.99	0.05	1.98	0.02	2.00	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		132
KQ90	3.90	-0.03	2.59	-0.01	2.58	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		99
KQ91	2.86	1.08	1.90	0.36	2.26	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		119
KQ92	5.13	-0.14	3.41	-0.05	3.36	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		29
KQ93	2.89	0.99	1.92	0.33	2.25	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		120
KQ94	3.24	0.22	2.15	0.07	2.22	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		121
KQ95	4.61	0.83	3.06	0.28	3.34	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		33
KQ96	3.24	1.26	2.15	0.42	2.57	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		100
KQ97	1.44	0.05	0.96	0.02	0.97	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		157
KQ98	3.82	0.44	2.54	0.15	2.69	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		89
KQ99	4.73	0.85	3.14	0.29	3.42	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		21
KQ100	1.99	-0.30	1.32	-0.10	1.22	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		152
KQ101	2.74	0.90	1.82	0.30	2.13	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		126
KQ102	4.74	0.09	3.15	0.03	3.18	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		48
KQ103	3.07	1.62	2.04	0.54	2.58	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		98
KQ104	4.83	0.55	3.20	0.19	3.39	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		25
KQ105	1.03	-0.55	0.68	-0.18	0.50	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		159
KQ106	3.59	0.41	2.38	0.14	2.52	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		106
KQ107	2.93	-0.06	1.94	-0.02	1.92	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		136
KQ108	2.51	1.47	1.67	0.49	2.16	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		124
KQ109	3.40	0.54	2.25	0.18	2.43	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		110
KQ110	5.40	0.33	3.59	0.11	3.70	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		9
KQ111	4.30	0.17	2.86	0.06	2.91	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		72
KQ112	4.35	0.55	2.89	0.18	3.07	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		58
KQ113	2.30	0.42	1.53	0.14	1.67	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		144
KQ114	5.37	0.03	3.56	0.01	3.57	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		15
KQ115	3.53	1.74	2.34	0.58	2.93	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		68
KQ116	1.70	0.96	1.13	0.32	1.45	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		149
KQ117	4.47	1.01	2.97	0.34	3.31	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		37
KQ118	3.62	0.96	2.40	0.32	2.72	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		86
KQ119	4.13	0.43	2.74	0.14	2.89	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		78
KQ120	2.51	0.49	1.67	0.16	1.83	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		141
KQ121	3.44	0.59	2.28	0.20	2.48	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		108
KQ122	4.71	0.11	3.12	0.04	3.16	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		50
KQ123	3.62	0.13	2.40	0.04	2.45	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		109
KQ124	5.46	0.06	3.62	0.02	3.64	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		10
KQ125	4.26	0.24	2.83	0.08	2.90	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		73
KQ126	5.33	0.28	3.54	0.09	3.63	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		12
KQ127	0.72	-0.22	0.48	-0.07	0.40	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		160
KQ128	4.35	-0.07	2.89	-0.02	2.86	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		79
KQ129	3.03	1.41	2.01	0.47	2.48	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		107
KQ130	4.63	0.17	3.07	0.06	3.13	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		52
KQ131	4.89	0.40	3.24	0.14	3.38	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		27
KQ132	5.98	-0.29	3.97	-0.10	3.87	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		4
KQ133	4.74	-0.03	3.15	-0.01	3.14	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		51
KQ134	5.82	0.06	3.86	0.02	3.88	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		3
KQ135	3.43	0.80	2.28	0.27	2.55	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		104
KQ136	2.49	1.01	1.65	0.34	1.99	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		134
KQ137	2.44	-0.18	1.62	-0.06	1.56	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		148
KQ138	4.55	0.72	3.02	0.24	3.26	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		43
KQ139	2.96	0.76	1.96	0.26	2.22	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		122
KQ140	2.95	1.09	1.95	0.37	2.32	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		115
KQ141	4.97	0.10	3.30	0.03	3.33	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		34
KQ142	4.30	0.79	2.85	0.27	3.12	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		53
KQ143	4.21	0.89	2.80	0.30	3.10	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		56
KQ144	1.83	-0.02	1.22	-0.01	1.21	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		153
KQ145	1.16	0.60	0.77	0.20	0.97	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive		158
KQ146	4.08	0.68	2.71	0.23	2.94	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		66
KQ147	3.17	0.87	2.10	0.29	2.40	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance		114
KQ148	4.60	0.05	3.05	0.02	3.07	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		59
KQ149	5.19	0.45	3.44	0.15	3.60	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		13
KQ150	4.80	0.64	3.19	0.22	3.40	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		23
KQ151	4.09	0.52	2.71	0.18	2.89	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		77
KQ152	4.41	1.04	2.93	0.35	3.28	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		41
KQ153	4.50	0.88	2.99	0.29	3.28	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		38
KQ154	4.04	0.34	2.68	0.11	2.80	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant		83
KQ155	2.60	0.32	1.72	0.11	1.83	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		142
KQ156	3.11	-0.02	2.06	-0.01	2.05	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive		129
KQ157	4.97	0.35	3.30	0.12	3.41	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		22
KQ158	4.66	0.74	3.09	0.25	3.34	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		32
KQ159	4.65	0.02	3.08	0.01	3.09	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		57
KQ160	5.34	0.29	3.54	0.10	3.64	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant		11
权重Wi				0.66	0.34

附表4

附表5

Na2CO3胁迫下苦荞种质萌发期的综合指标、隶属函数值、D值和排序"

编号 Number	综合指标值 Value of composite indicator		隶属函数值 Value of the affiliation function		D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
编号 Number	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	Ⅰ	Ⅱ	D值 D-value	综合评价 Comprehensive evaluation	排序 Rank
KQ1	3.17	0.34	2.19	0.10	2.30	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	123
KQ2	5.10	0.67	3.53	0.21	3.73	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	21
KQ3	4.27	0.91	2.95	0.28	3.23	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	60
KQ4	2.86	1.18	1.98	0.36	2.34	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	119
KQ5	5.00	0.68	3.46	0.21	3.67	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	27
KQ6	3.70	-0.51	2.56	-0.16	2.40	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	117
KQ7	3.64	1.08	2.52	0.33	2.85	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	90
KQ8	1.82	0.00	1.26	0.00	1.26	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	154
KQ9	5.45	0.87	3.77	0.27	4.04	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	7
KQ10	1.31	0.55	0.90	0.17	1.07	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	156
KQ11	4.75	0.49	3.28	0.15	3.43	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	44
KQ12	4.60	0.72	3.18	0.22	3.40	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	46
KQ13	3.80	0.94	2.63	0.29	2.92	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	83
KQ14	4.12	0.80	2.85	0.25	3.10	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	71
KQ15	4.26	0.90	2.94	0.28	3.22	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	61
KQ16	2.45	-0.81	1.69	-0.25	1.44	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	148
KQ17	4.79	1.07	3.31	0.33	3.64	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	28
KQ18	4.01	-0.36	2.77	-0.11	2.66	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	107
KQ19	3.59	1.32	2.48	0.41	2.89	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	87
KQ20	4.15	-0.78	2.87	-0.24	2.63	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	108
KQ21	4.42	0.87	3.06	0.27	3.32	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	54
KQ22	3.21	0.36	2.22	0.11	2.33	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	120
KQ23	2.83	0.73	1.96	0.23	2.19	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	131
KQ24	4.66	0.57	3.22	0.18	3.40	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	48
KQ25	2.71	1.27	1.87	0.39	2.26	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	126
KQ26	5.68	0.66	3.93	0.20	4.13	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	4
KQ27	2.98	1.36	2.06	0.42	2.48	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	115
KQ28	3.56	1.42	2.46	0.44	2.90	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	86
KQ29	5.88	0.70	4.07	0.22	4.29	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	2
KQ30	5.45	0.12	3.77	0.04	3.80	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	16
KQ31	4.16	1.07	2.87	0.33	3.20	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	62
KQ32	4.15	1.34	2.87	0.41	3.28	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	57
KQ33	3.96	1.08	2.74	0.33	3.07	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	75
KQ34	3.85	0.51	2.67	0.16	2.82	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	92
KQ35	3.49	1.07	2.42	0.33	2.75	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	98
KQ36	5.04	0.80	3.48	0.25	3.73	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	23
KQ37	3.22	1.08	2.23	0.33	2.56	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	111
KQ38	2.76	-0.23	1.91	-0.07	1.84	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	139
KQ39	5.50	-0.43	3.80	-0.13	3.67	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	26
KQ40	3.10	0.17	2.14	0.05	2.20	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	129
KQ41	3.68	0.94	2.54	0.29	2.83	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	91
KQ42	4.00	0.50	2.77	0.16	2.92	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	81
KQ43	2.08	0.12	1.44	0.04	1.48	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	146
KQ44	4.66	0.58	3.22	0.18	3.40	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	47
KQ45	6.13	0.31	4.24	0.10	4.33	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	1
KQ46	5.23	-0.11	3.62	-0.03	3.58	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	32
KQ47	2.41	-0.11	1.67	-0.03	1.63	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	145
KQ48	2.80	0.13	1.94	0.04	1.98	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	137
KQ49	3.70	1.13	2.56	0.35	2.91	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	85
KQ50	4.32	0.42	2.98	0.13	3.11	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	69
KQ51	1.88	-0.07	1.30	-0.02	1.28	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	153
KQ52	3.19	0.40	2.20	0.12	2.33	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	121
KQ53	2.70	-0.21	1.87	-0.07	1.80	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	142
KQ54	4.66	0.81	3.22	0.25	3.47	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	40
KQ55	3.44	1.27	2.38	0.39	2.77	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	94
KQ56	4.17	0.90	2.88	0.28	3.16	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	64
KQ57	4.85	0.02	3.35	0.01	3.36	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	51
KQ58	4.46	1.25	3.08	0.39	3.47	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	41
KQ59	4.50	0.07	3.11	0.02	3.14	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	66
KQ60	3.73	0.44	2.58	0.14	2.71	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	100
KQ61	3.96	1.11	2.74	0.34	3.08	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	73
KQ62	5.29	0.59	3.66	0.18	3.84	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	15
KQ63	3.60	0.91	2.49	0.28	2.77	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	95
KQ64	4.99	0.54	3.45	0.17	3.62	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	30
KQ65	2.69	-0.20	1.86	-0.06	1.80	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	143
KQ66	5.60	0.61	3.87	0.19	4.06	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	6
KQ67	4.04	0.89	2.79	0.27	3.07	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	77
KQ68	3.45	1.04	2.38	0.32	2.70	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	103
KQ69	5.47	0.63	3.79	0.19	3.98	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	10
KQ70	4.76	0.90	3.29	0.28	3.57	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	33
KQ71	3.64	1.19	2.52	0.37	2.88	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	88
KQ72	5.37	0.29	3.71	0.09	3.80	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	17
KQ73	5.62	-0.41	3.89	-0.13	3.76	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	18
KQ74	4.84	0.43	3.35	0.13	3.48	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	39
KQ75	5.20	0.48	3.60	0.15	3.75	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	19
KQ76	2.73	-0.18	1.89	-0.06	1.83	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	140
KQ77	3.48	0.96	2.41	0.30	2.70	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	104
KQ78	4.03	0.99	2.79	0.30	3.09	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	72
KQ79	3.76	1.04	2.60	0.32	2.92	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	82
KQ80	2.48	-0.05	1.71	-0.02	1.70	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	144
KQ81	1.88	0.52	1.30	0.16	1.46	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	147
KQ82	4.04	0.88	2.80	0.27	3.07	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	76
KQ83	3.71	0.64	2.57	0.20	2.76	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	96
KQ84	3.49	0.97	2.41	0.30	2.71	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	101
KQ85	3.79	0.77	2.62	0.24	2.86	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	89
KQ86	2.48	1.14	1.71	0.35	2.06	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	136
KQ87	3.12	1.09	2.16	0.33	2.50	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	114
KQ88	3.37	-0.46	2.33	-0.14	2.19	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	130
KQ89	3.06	0.12	2.12	0.04	2.15	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	134
KQ90	4.05	0.02	2.80	0.01	2.81	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	93
KQ91	2.70	1.01	1.87	0.31	2.18	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	132
KQ92	5.17	-0.06	3.57	-0.02	3.56	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	34
KQ93	3.01	1.02	2.08	0.31	2.39	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	118
KQ94	3.53	0.31	2.44	0.10	2.54	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	113
KQ95	4.62	0.83	3.19	0.25	3.45	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	42
KQ96	3.42	1.29	2.37	0.40	2.76	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	97
KQ97	0.96	0.35	0.66	0.11	0.77	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	158
KQ98	3.99	0.58	2.76	0.18	2.94	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	80
KQ99	4.99	0.90	3.45	0.28	3.73	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	22
KQ100	1.56	-0.02	1.08	-0.01	1.08	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	155
KQ101	2.61	0.96	1.81	0.30	2.10	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	135
KQ102	4.89	0.19	3.38	0.06	3.44	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	43
KQ103	3.22	1.55	2.23	0.48	2.71	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	102
KQ104	4.95	0.60	3.42	0.19	3.61	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	31
KQ105	0.53	-0.23	0.37	-0.07	0.30	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	160
KQ106	3.71	0.37	2.56	0.12	2.68	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	106
KQ107	3.24	0.08	2.24	0.02	2.27	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	125
KQ108	2.69	1.51	1.86	0.46	2.32	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	122
KQ109	3.22	0.73	2.22	0.22	2.45	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	116
KQ110	5.62	0.46	3.89	0.14	4.03	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	8
KQ111	4.49	0.22	3.10	0.07	3.17	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	63
KQ112	4.46	0.59	3.08	0.18	3.26	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	59
KQ113	2.43	0.45	1.68	0.14	1.82	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	141
KQ114	5.55	0.16	3.84	0.05	3.88	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	14
KQ115	3.65	1.70	2.52	0.53	3.05	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	78
KQ116	1.61	0.80	1.11	0.25	1.36	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	150
KQ117	4.68	1.02	3.24	0.31	3.55	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	35
KQ118	3.77	1.00	2.61	0.31	2.92	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	84
KQ119	4.29	0.45	2.96	0.14	3.10	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	70
KQ120	2.64	0.46	1.82	0.14	1.97	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	138
KQ121	3.61	0.61	2.50	0.19	2.69	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	105
KQ122	4.88	0.14	3.37	0.04	3.42	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	45
KQ123	3.54	0.40	2.45	0.12	2.57	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	110
KQ124	5.66	0.16	3.91	0.05	3.96	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	11
KQ125	4.39	0.26	3.04	0.08	3.12	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	68
KQ126	5.49	0.39	3.80	0.12	3.92	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	13
KQ127	0.75	-0.19	0.52	-0.06	0.46	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	159
KQ128	4.51	0.01	3.12	0.00	3.13	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	67
KQ129	3.13	1.44	2.17	0.44	2.61	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	109
KQ130	4.79	0.26	3.31	0.08	3.39	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	49
KQ131	5.12	0.46	3.54	0.14	3.68	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	25
KQ132	5.97	-0.02	4.13	-0.01	4.12	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	5
KQ133	4.88	0.06	3.37	0.02	3.39	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	50
KQ134	6.06	0.15	4.19	0.05	4.24	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	3
KQ135	3.56	0.83	2.46	0.26	2.72	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	99
KQ136	2.71	0.96	1.87	0.30	2.17	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	133
KQ137	1.81	0.09	1.25	0.03	1.28	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	152
KQ138	4.74	0.80	3.28	0.25	3.52	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	36
KQ139	2.80	0.85	1.94	0.26	2.20	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	128
KQ140	2.68	1.16	1.85	0.36	2.21	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	127
KQ141	5.14	0.22	3.56	0.07	3.63	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	29
KQ142	4.47	0.81	3.09	0.25	3.34	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	52
KQ143	4.37	0.87	3.02	0.27	3.29	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	56
KQ144	1.94	0.03	1.34	0.01	1.35	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	151
KQ145	1.18	0.58	0.82	0.18	1.00	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	157
KQ146	4.23	0.72	2.92	0.22	3.15	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	65
KQ147	3.29	0.88	2.28	0.27	2.55	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	112
KQ148	4.78	0.11	3.30	0.03	3.34	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	53
KQ149	5.43	0.57	3.76	0.17	3.93	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	12
KQ150	5.09	0.74	3.52	0.23	3.75	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	20
KQ151	4.23	0.50	2.92	0.15	3.08	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	74
KQ152	4.34	0.89	3.00	0.28	3.28	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	58
KQ153	4.65	0.95	3.21	0.29	3.51	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	38
KQ154	4.08	0.51	2.82	0.16	2.98	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	79
KQ155	1.78	0.48	1.23	0.15	1.38	碱极敏感型Extremely alkali-sensitive	149
KQ156	3.28	0.08	2.27	0.03	2.30	碱敏感型Alkali-sensitive	124
KQ157	5.15	0.45	3.56	0.14	3.70	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	24
KQ158	4.77	0.71	3.30	0.22	3.52	较耐碱型Alkali-tolerant	37
KQ159	4.74	0.09	3.28	0.03	3.31	中等耐碱型Moderate alkali-tolerance	55
KQ160	5.58	0.40	3.86	0.12	3.98	高耐碱型High alkali-resistant	9
Wi			0.69	0.31

附表5

图2

图3

表6

附表6

NaCl回归方程的估计精度分析"

编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)	编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)
KQ1	2.019	2.006	0.013	99.346	KQ81	1.633	1.633	0.001	99.961
KQ2	3.390	3.379	0.012	99.659	KQ82	2.875	2.848	0.027	99.077
KQ3	2.928	2.902	0.026	99.109	KQ83	2.665	2.648	0.016	99.394
KQ4	2.384	2.303	0.081	96.593	KQ84	2.485	2.511	-0.026	98.954
KQ5	3.452	3.446	0.005	99.842	KQ85	2.643	2.582	0.061	97.690
KQ6	2.296	2.233	0.063	97.257	KQ86	1.861	1.846	0.015	99.211
KQ7	2.639	2.616	0.024	99.098	KQ87	2.214	2.147	0.066	96.998
KQ8	1.433	1.384	0.049	96.590	KQ88	1.952	1.881	0.071	96.368
KQ9	3.711	3.699	0.012	99.663	KQ89	1.976	1.950	0.026	98.664
KQ10	1.251	1.273	-0.022	98.213	KQ90	2.613	2.579	0.034	98.716
KQ11	3.312	3.272	0.040	98.797	KQ91	2.243	2.163	0.080	96.433
KQ12	3.161	3.156	0.005	99.847	KQ92	3.421	3.434	-0.013	99.612
KQ13	2.739	2.725	0.014	99.487	KQ93	2.194	2.175	0.019	99.146
KQ14	2.940	2.875	0.064	97.810	KQ94	2.166	2.173	-0.007	99.695
KQ15	2.960	2.931	0.029	99.013	KQ95	3.224	3.181	0.043	98.663
KQ16	1.833	1.798	0.035	98.076	KQ96	2.439	2.454	-0.016	99.364
KQ17	3.265	3.227	0.037	98.854	KQ97	1.202	1.214	-0.012	98.966
KQ18	2.711	2.680	0.031	98.863	KQ98	2.768	2.732	0.035	98.720
KQ19	2.669	2.672	-0.004	99.864	KQ99	3.443	3.392	0.051	98.515
KQ20	2.662	2.654	0.008	99.699	KQ100	1.824	1.791	0.033	98.166
KQ21	3.094	3.121	-0.027	99.138	KQ101	2.100	2.044	0.056	97.353
KQ22	1.780	1.797	-0.017	99.050	KQ102	3.309	3.293	0.016	99.506
KQ23	1.811	1.817	-0.006	99.685	KQ103	2.519	2.483	0.035	98.592
KQ24	3.217	3.187	0.030	99.076	KQ104	3.453	3.415	0.038	98.900
KQ25	1.973	2.001	-0.027	98.616	KQ105	0.565	0.581	-0.016	97.189
KQ26	3.750	3.765	-0.015	99.598	KQ106	2.482	2.441	0.040	98.371
KQ27	2.219	2.211	0.008	99.626	KQ107	1.848	1.852	-0.005	99.746
KQ28	2.648	2.629	0.019	99.274	KQ108	2.240	2.240	0.000	99.985
KQ29	3.961	3.963	-0.002	99.938	KQ109	2.000	1.987	0.013	99.335
KQ30	3.456	3.439	0.018	99.490	KQ110	3.861	3.802	0.059	98.478
KQ31	2.923	2.870	0.053	98.192	KQ111	2.908	2.908	-0.001	99.982
KQ32	2.963	2.933	0.030	98.991	KQ112	3.174	3.102	0.072	97.716
KQ33	2.798	2.786	0.012	99.588	KQ113	1.672	1.672	0.000	99.990
KQ34	2.433	2.382	0.051	97.885	KQ114	3.659	3.633	0.026	99.303
KQ35	2.509	2.504	0.005	99.783	KQ115	2.674	2.647	0.027	98.985
KQ36	3.403	3.396	0.007	99.795	KQ116	1.864	1.890	-0.026	98.595
KQ37	2.382	2.413	-0.031	98.713	KQ117	3.225	3.191	0.035	98.920
KQ38	2.089	2.030	0.059	97.160	KQ118	2.772	2.752	0.021	99.251
KQ39	3.463	3.435	0.028	99.183	KQ119	2.896	2.869	0.027	99.076
KQ40	2.383	2.356	0.027	98.851	KQ120	1.750	1.687	0.062	96.441
KQ41	2.590	2.538	0.051	98.025	KQ121	2.530	2.478	0.052	97.927
KQ42	2.802	2.751	0.051	98.173	KQ122	3.183	3.184	0.000	99.987
KQ43	2.122	2.084	0.038	98.189	KQ123	2.099	2.082	0.017	99.202
KQ44	3.114	3.047	0.067	97.846	KQ124	3.887	3.826	0.062	98.415
KQ45	4.018	3.985	0.033	99.168	KQ125	2.957	2.919	0.039	98.694
KQ46	3.350	3.358	-0.008	99.752	KQ126	3.784	3.733	0.051	98.654
KQ47	1.777	1.774	0.003	99.821	KQ127	0.850	0.876	-0.026	96.916
KQ48	2.462	2.431	0.031	98.731	KQ128	2.953	2.917	0.036	98.788
KQ49	2.614	2.612	0.002	99.926	KQ129	2.388	2.369	0.019	99.201
KQ50	2.995	2.918	0.077	97.433	KQ130	3.170	3.148	0.022	99.292
KQ51	0.940	0.935	0.005	99.482	KQ131	3.400	3.385	0.015	99.558
KQ52	2.008	1.998	0.011	99.474	KQ132	4.018	4.027	-0.008	99.797
KQ53	1.170	1.143	0.027	97.690	KQ133	3.240	3.226	0.014	99.561
KQ54	3.162	3.110	0.051	98.371	KQ134	3.980	4.003	-0.023	99.424
KQ55	2.313	2.338	-0.024	98.948	KQ135	2.553	2.524	0.029	98.867
KQ56	3.046	3.003	0.043	98.599	KQ136	1.943	1.911	0.033	98.322
KQ57	3.162	3.141	0.021	99.330	KQ137	1.426	1.438	-0.013	99.114
KQ58	3.239	3.203	0.036	98.888	KQ138	3.217	3.209	0.008	99.747
KQ59	2.956	2.933	0.023	99.213	KQ139	1.962	1.912	0.050	97.465
KQ60	2.307	2.286	0.021	99.094	KQ140	2.319	2.294	0.025	98.939
KQ61	2.905	2.864	0.041	98.595	KQ141	3.354	3.355	-0.002	99.946
KQ62	3.633	3.597	0.036	99.017	KQ142	3.172	3.117	0.054	98.292
KQ63	2.393	2.419	-0.027	98.885	KQ143	2.976	2.957	0.019	99.356
KQ64	3.362	3.341	0.021	99.389	KQ144	1.221	1.223	-0.001	99.879
KQ65	1.980	1.947	0.033	98.330	KQ145	1.556	1.550	0.007	99.566
KQ66	3.831	3.826	0.006	99.856	KQ146	2.985	2.937	0.048	98.389
KQ67	2.911	2.900	0.011	99.632	KQ147	2.438	2.435	0.003	99.868
KQ68	2.533	2.488	0.045	98.221	KQ148	2.918	2.891	0.027	99.078
KQ69	3.654	3.662	-0.008	99.773	KQ149	3.601	3.595	0.006	99.835
KQ70	3.294	3.291	0.003	99.901	KQ150	3.410	3.379	0.031	99.076
KQ71	2.714	2.712	0.002	99.925	KQ151	2.879	2.847	0.031	98.916
KQ72	3.540	3.523	0.017	99.522	KQ152	3.145	3.159	-0.015	99.532
KQ73	3.674	3.640	0.034	99.085	KQ153	3.364	3.345	0.019	99.436
KQ74	3.283	3.255	0.028	99.143	KQ154	2.646	2.627	0.018	99.310
KQ75	3.409	3.387	0.022	99.349	KQ155	2.211	2.203	0.007	99.670
KQ76	2.102	2.067	0.035	98.357	KQ156	2.110	2.042	0.068	96.792
KQ77	2.506	2.435	0.071	97.147	KQ157	3.486	3.440	0.046	98.674
KQ78	2.734	2.693	0.041	98.498	KQ158	3.248	3.204	0.045	98.628
KQ79	2.586	2.538	0.048	98.152	KQ159	3.129	3.114	0.014	99.543
KQ80	2.178	2.146	0.032	98.511	KQ160	3.626	3.614	0.012	99.657

附表6

附表7

Na2SO4回归方程的估计精度分析"

编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)	编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)
KQ1	2.445	2.478	-0.033	98.667	KQ81	2.211	2.236	-0.025	98.866
KQ2	3.619	3.626	-0.007	99.820	KQ82	3.204	3.222	-0.018	99.452
KQ3	3.382	3.388	-0.007	99.802	KQ83	3.083	3.093	-0.010	99.673
KQ4	2.782	2.751	0.031	98.884	KQ84	2.951	2.974	-0.023	99.204
KQ5	3.627	3.668	-0.041	98.856	KQ85	3.092	3.071	0.020	99.343
KQ6	2.687	2.652	0.035	98.707	KQ86	2.391	2.453	-0.062	97.408
KQ7	3.044	3.062	-0.018	99.394	KQ87	2.797	2.754	0.043	98.467
KQ8	1.893	1.965	-0.072	96.219	KQ88	2.497	2.503	-0.006	99.756
KQ9	3.901	3.958	-0.057	98.549	KQ89	2.616	2.647	-0.031	98.799
KQ10	1.941	1.924	0.017	99.124	KQ90	3.032	3.021	0.011	99.644
KQ11	3.547	3.524	0.023	99.344	KQ91	2.705	2.696	0.009	99.682
KQ12	3.500	3.498	0.002	99.953	KQ92	3.617	3.658	-0.041	98.872
KQ13	3.151	3.164	-0.013	99.590	KQ93	2.708	2.754	-0.046	98.312
KQ14	3.305	3.293	0.012	99.643	KQ94	2.625	2.659	-0.034	98.697
KQ15	3.366	3.345	0.021	99.373	KQ95	3.449	3.468	-0.018	99.468
KQ16	2.450	2.332	0.118	95.172	KQ96	2.963	2.962	0.001	99.963
KQ17	3.517	3.543	-0.026	99.251	KQ97	2.223	2.197	0.026	98.824
KQ18	3.020	3.042	-0.022	99.275	KQ98	3.171	3.180	-0.009	99.720
KQ19	3.117	3.158	-0.041	98.675	KQ99	3.621	3.637	-0.017	99.536
KQ20	2.871	2.912	-0.042	98.553	KQ100	2.047	2.151	-0.104	94.939
KQ21	3.436	3.512	-0.076	97.786	KQ101	2.533	2.521	0.012	99.523
KQ22	2.364	2.422	-0.057	97.576	KQ102	3.569	3.589	-0.021	99.418
KQ23	2.354	2.422	-0.068	97.093	KQ103	2.947	2.964	-0.017	99.433
KQ24	3.471	3.474	-0.003	99.917	KQ104	3.683	3.674	0.010	99.737
KQ25	2.569	2.624	-0.056	97.826	KQ105	1.079	1.058	0.021	98.089
KQ26	3.989	4.048	-0.059	98.530	KQ106	2.994	2.971	0.023	99.241
KQ27	2.732	2.787	-0.055	97.998	KQ107	2.366	2.405	-0.039	98.338
KQ28	3.140	3.161	-0.021	99.346	KQ108	2.763	2.789	-0.026	99.070
KQ29	4.074	4.141	-0.067	98.344	KQ109	2.450	2.500	-0.049	97.981
KQ30	3.658	3.713	-0.055	98.508	KQ110	3.861	3.873	-0.012	99.695
KQ31	3.330	3.319	0.011	99.673	KQ111	3.285	3.296	-0.011	99.651
KQ32	3.366	3.357	0.009	99.730	KQ112	3.675	3.693	-0.018	99.519
KQ33	3.229	3.244	-0.015	99.529	KQ113	2.266	2.294	-0.028	98.775
KQ34	2.911	2.866	0.045	98.455	KQ114	3.808	3.826	-0.018	99.522
KQ35	2.985	3.044	-0.058	98.042	KQ115	3.164	3.134	0.030	99.048
KQ36	3.697	3.727	-0.031	99.172	KQ116	2.435	2.500	-0.065	97.326
KQ37	2.900	2.937	-0.036	98.749	KQ117	3.560	3.568	-0.008	99.774
KQ38	2.737	2.702	0.035	98.728	KQ118	3.153	3.185	-0.032	98.976
KQ39	3.551	3.615	-0.063	98.216	KQ119	3.270	3.273	-0.003	99.904
KQ40	2.839	2.807	0.033	98.853	KQ120	2.453	2.393	0.060	97.550
KQ41	3.437	3.332	0.105	96.938	KQ121	2.979	2.945	0.034	98.858
KQ42	3.115	3.140	-0.026	99.180	KQ122	3.493	3.540	-0.047	98.664
KQ43	2.430	2.516	-0.085	96.489	KQ123	2.604	2.635	-0.031	98.824
KQ44	3.462	3.490	-0.028	99.188	KQ124	3.928	3.938	-0.010	99.739
KQ45	4.075	4.115	-0.040	99.009	KQ125	3.281	3.292	-0.012	99.644
KQ46	3.571	3.613	-0.042	98.834	KQ126	3.824	3.859	-0.035	99.081
KQ47	2.367	2.352	0.015	99.369	KQ127	1.733	1.798	-0.065	96.239
KQ48	2.901	2.909	-0.008	99.711	KQ128	3.314	3.323	-0.009	99.720
KQ49	3.069	3.076	-0.007	99.771	KQ129	2.910	2.932	-0.022	99.227
KQ50	3.283	3.259	0.024	99.280	KQ130	3.466	3.485	-0.019	99.445
KQ51	1.679	1.735	-0.056	96.683	KQ131	3.624	3.676	-0.052	98.564
KQ52	2.354	2.447	-0.093	96.033	KQ132	3.955	4.062	-0.107	97.291
KQ53	1.948	1.954	-0.006	99.685	KQ133	3.478	3.523	-0.045	98.700
KQ54	3.434	3.431	0.004	99.886	KQ134	4.009	4.081	-0.072	98.207
KQ55	2.832	3.012	-0.179	93.663	KQ135	3.010	3.050	-0.040	98.683
KQ56	3.307	3.322	-0.015	99.544	KQ136	2.520	2.544	-0.024	99.050
KQ57	3.446	3.478	-0.032	99.084	KQ137	2.324	2.247	0.077	96.686
KQ58	3.548	3.535	0.013	99.641	KQ138	3.560	3.594	-0.034	99.044
KQ59	3.258	3.303	-0.045	98.609	KQ139	2.649	2.578	0.071	97.308
KQ60	2.681	2.724	-0.043	98.397	KQ140	2.818	2.877	-0.059	97.889
KQ61	3.340	3.301	0.039	98.841	KQ141	3.632	3.653	-0.021	99.412
KQ62	3.826	3.828	-0.002	99.961	KQ142	3.458	3.426	0.032	99.072
KQ63	2.959	2.930	0.030	99.002	KQ143	3.305	3.311	-0.005	99.841
KQ64	3.586	3.656	-0.070	98.053	KQ144	1.886	1.913	-0.028	98.540
KQ65	2.656	2.624	0.032	98.778	KQ145	2.143	2.110	0.033	98.464
KQ66	3.856	3.718	0.138	96.420	KQ146	3.304	3.275	0.029	99.109
KQ67	3.200	3.209	-0.009	99.712	KQ147	2.930	2.967	-0.037	98.748
KQ68	3.108	3.030	0.078	97.499	KQ148	3.323	3.404	-0.081	97.554
KQ69	3.872	3.938	-0.067	98.280	KQ149	3.835	3.885	-0.050	98.696
KQ70	3.626	3.636	-0.010	99.721	KQ150	3.648	3.696	-0.048	98.676
KQ71	3.176	3.219	-0.042	98.665	KQ151	3.225	3.212	0.013	99.584
KQ72	3.724	3.782	-0.058	98.446	KQ152	3.490	3.517	-0.027	99.226
KQ73	3.761	3.784	-0.024	99.366	KQ153	3.575	3.593	-0.019	99.475
KQ74	3.533	3.556	-0.023	99.360	KQ154	2.902	2.949	-0.047	98.369
KQ75	3.661	3.695	-0.034	99.069	KQ155	2.600	2.588	0.012	99.534
KQ76	2.611	2.586	0.025	99.041	KQ156	2.569	2.551	0.018	99.303
KQ77	3.013	2.971	0.042	98.605	KQ157	3.690	3.671	0.018	99.501
KQ78	3.234	3.186	0.047	98.532	KQ158	3.520	3.535	-0.014	99.593
KQ79	3.035	3.008	0.027	99.126	KQ159	3.399	3.425	-0.026	99.227
KQ80	2.725	2.721	0.004	99.853	KQ160	3.835	3.895	-0.060	98.434

附表7

附表8

NaHCO3回归方程的估计精度分析"

编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)	编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)
KQ1	2.034	2.050	-0.016	99.227	KQ81	1.357	1.433	-0.076	94.374
KQ2	3.517	3.575	-0.058	98.365	KQ82	2.925	2.983	-0.058	98.034
KQ3	3.042	3.054	-0.012	99.593	KQ83	2.573	2.609	-0.036	98.603
KQ4	2.408	2.377	0.030	98.734	KQ84	2.601	2.669	-0.067	97.419
KQ5	3.374	3.429	-0.055	98.363	KQ85	2.685	2.676	0.009	99.678
KQ6	2.215	2.213	0.002	99.893	KQ86	1.876	1.918	-0.041	97.793
KQ7	2.705	2.771	-0.066	97.555	KQ87	2.543	2.524	0.019	99.268
KQ8	1.130	1.159	-0.029	97.470	KQ88	1.903	1.896	0.007	99.621
KQ9	3.757	3.826	-0.069	98.156	KQ89	2.001	2.010	-0.009	99.551
KQ10	1.041	1.123	-0.082	92.138	KQ90	2.577	2.588	-0.012	99.541
KQ11	3.211	3.219	-0.008	99.735	KQ91	2.259	2.227	0.032	98.571
KQ12	3.180	3.208	-0.028	99.115	KQ92	3.362	3.430	-0.068	97.977
KQ13	2.805	2.862	-0.057	97.961	KQ93	2.247	2.300	-0.053	97.633
KQ14	2.931	2.926	0.006	99.811	KQ94	2.224	2.272	-0.048	97.844
KQ15	3.024	3.034	-0.010	99.682	KQ95	3.335	3.391	-0.055	98.339
KQ16	1.633	1.629	0.004	99.753	KQ96	2.573	2.630	-0.056	97.811
KQ17	3.349	3.399	-0.050	98.505	KQ97	0.974	1.022	-0.048	95.115
KQ18	2.597	2.629	-0.031	98.796	KQ98	2.685	2.712	-0.027	98.994
KQ19	2.800	2.883	-0.082	97.063	KQ99	3.422	3.463	-0.041	98.789
KQ20	2.405	2.446	-0.041	98.304	KQ100	1.222	1.252	-0.030	97.569
KQ21	3.106	3.198	-0.091	97.060	KQ101	2.125	2.090	0.035	98.376
KQ22	2.101	2.114	-0.012	99.425	KQ102	3.178	3.219	-0.041	98.705
KQ23	2.023	2.064	-0.042	97.943	KQ103	2.580	2.615	-0.035	98.645
KQ24	3.257	3.314	-0.057	98.250	KQ104	3.390	3.401	-0.011	99.671
KQ25	2.135	2.212	-0.077	96.370	KQ105	0.497	0.519	-0.062	95.555
KQ26	3.832	3.903	-0.071	98.139	KQ106	2.522	2.546	-0.025	99.023
KQ27	2.313	2.377	-0.064	97.246	KQ107	1.924	1.967	-0.043	97.786
KQ28	2.797	2.832	-0.035	98.756	KQ108	2.161	2.202	-0.041	98.103
KQ29	3.989	4.085	-0.096	97.606	KQ109	2.434	2.480	-0.045	98.133
KQ30	3.429	3.492	-0.063	98.168	KQ110	3.697	3.734	-0.037	99.003
KQ31	3.022	3.032	-0.010	99.660	KQ111	2.915	2.947	-0.032	98.893
KQ32	3.321	3.331	-0.010	99.694	KQ112	3.072	3.072	0.000	99.999
KQ33	2.951	3.003	-0.052	98.226	KQ113	1.668	1.721	-0.053	96.834
KQ34	2.586	2.569	0.017	99.339	KQ114	3.572	3.619	-0.047	98.685
KQ35	2.573	2.621	-0.048	98.122	KQ115	2.926	2.936	-0.010	99.663
KQ36	3.470	3.514	-0.045	98.705	KQ116	1.452	1.572	-0.120	91.739
KQ37	2.409	2.465	-0.056	97.667	KQ117	3.307	3.334	-0.027	99.179
KQ38	1.985	1.969	0.016	99.205	KQ118	2.724	2.770	-0.046	98.317
KQ39	3.329	3.411	-0.083	97.520	KQ119	2.888	2.918	-0.030	98.963
KQ40	2.117	2.166	-0.049	97.676	KQ120	1.833	1.788	0.045	97.546
KQ41	2.673	2.662	0.011	99.593	KQ121	2.482	2.472	0.010	99.582
KQ42	2.898	2.931	-0.033	98.848	KQ122	3.161	3.214	-0.052	98.349
KQ43	1.595	1.639	-0.044	97.268	KQ123	2.447	2.481	-0.034	98.618
KQ44	3.168	3.208	-0.040	98.730	KQ124	3.643	3.678	-0.036	99.024
KQ45	3.954	4.023	-0.069	98.254	KQ125	2.905	2.932	-0.027	99.069
KQ46	3.278	3.340	-0.062	98.119	KQ126	3.632	3.665	-0.033	99.081
KQ47	1.575	1.612	-0.038	97.611	KQ127	0.402	0.425	-0.024	94.061
KQ48	1.917	1.948	-0.031	98.401	KQ128	2.865	2.892	-0.027	99.058
KQ49	2.754	2.801	-0.046	98.321	KQ129	2.482	2.511	-0.029	98.824
KQ50	2.904	2.894	0.009	99.681	KQ130	3.126	3.165	-0.039	98.764
KQ51	1.116	1.138	-0.022	98.030	KQ131	3.378	3.437	-0.060	98.228
KQ52	2.260	2.288	-0.028	98.765	KQ132	3.871	3.973	-0.102	97.366
KQ53	1.319	1.335	-0.016	98.775	KQ133	3.136	3.191	-0.054	98.273
KQ54	3.274	3.310	-0.036	98.886	KQ134	3.885	3.992	-0.107	97.252
KQ55	2.630	2.713	-0.083	96.833	KQ135	2.546	2.592	-0.046	98.192
KQ56	2.945	2.974	-0.030	98.996	KQ136	1.990	1.996	-0.006	99.720
KQ57	3.106	3.154	-0.048	98.468	KQ137	1.558	1.550	0.009	99.442
KQ58	3.280	3.284	-0.004	99.880	KQ138	3.262	3.313	-0.051	98.432
KQ59	2.900	2.933	-0.032	98.884	KQ139	2.218	2.192	0.026	98.830
KQ60	2.277	2.329	-0.052	97.701	KQ140	2.323	2.387	-0.065	97.211
KQ61	2.920	2.915	0.004	99.848	KQ141	3.334	3.387	-0.053	98.420
KQ62	3.585	3.611	-0.026	99.281	KQ142	3.120	3.117	0.003	99.905
KQ63	2.623	2.678	-0.055	97.895	KQ143	3.097	3.147	-0.051	98.361
KQ64	3.394	3.451	-0.057	98.320	KQ144	1.209	1.255	-0.046	96.189
KQ65	1.998	1.991	0.007	99.665	KQ145	0.967	0.980	-0.112	98.719
KQ66	3.765	3.847	-0.083	97.802	KQ146	2.938	2.937	0.001	99.976
KQ67	2.920	2.968	-0.048	98.341	KQ147	2.397	2.437	-0.040	98.338
KQ68	2.581	2.567	0.014	99.469	KQ148	3.071	3.112	-0.041	98.659
KQ69	3.714	3.793	-0.079	97.873	KQ149	3.597	3.657	-0.060	98.335
KQ70	3.383	3.417	-0.034	99.001	KQ150	3.404	3.466	-0.062	98.190
KQ71	2.743	2.795	-0.052	98.116	KQ151	2.889	2.922	-0.033	98.845
KQ72	3.512	3.587	-0.075	97.872	KQ152	3.277	3.358	-0.081	97.541
KQ73	3.493	3.532	-0.039	98.882	KQ153	3.282	3.318	-0.036	98.905
KQ74	3.199	3.237	-0.037	98.839	KQ154	2.797	2.856	-0.059	97.890
KQ75	3.350	3.390	-0.040	98.795	KQ155	1.833	1.901	-0.068	96.285
KQ76	1.915	1.913	0.001	99.938	KQ156	2.055	2.066	-0.011	99.465
KQ77	2.547	2.526	0.021	99.195	KQ157	3.415	3.433	-0.018	99.472
KQ78	2.949	2.947	0.002	99.938	KQ158	3.344	3.401	-0.057	98.303
KQ79	2.674	2.681	-0.007	99.743	KQ159	3.091	3.123	-0.031	98.987
KQ80	1.758	1.784	-0.026	98.534	KQ160	3.642	3.688	-0.046	98.748

附表8

附表9

Na2CO3回归方程的估计精度分析"

编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)	编号 Number	D值 D-value	回归值 Regression value	拟合误差 Fitting error	估计精度 Evaluation accuracy (%)
KQ1	2.297	2.239	0.058	97.474	KQ81	1.460	1.513	-0.053	96.399
KQ2	3.734	3.747	-0.013	99.663	KQ82	3.069	3.061	0.008	99.743
KQ3	3.234	3.221	0.013	99.597	KQ83	2.764	2.765	-0.001	99.980
KQ4	2.342	2.292	0.050	97.854	KQ84	2.710	2.724	-0.013	99.502
KQ5	3.666	3.695	-0.029	99.215	KQ85	2.860	2.804	0.057	98.019
KQ6	2.403	2.400	0.003	99.872	KQ86	2.063	2.075	-0.012	99.407
KQ7	2.849	2.931	-0.082	97.136	KQ87	2.496	2.450	0.046	98.162
KQ8	1.259	1.251	0.008	99.331	KQ88	2.189	2.203	-0.014	99.382
KQ9	4.039	4.050	-0.011	99.736	KQ89	2.153	2.192	-0.039	98.187
KQ10	1.072	1.035	0.037	96.560	KQ90	2.806	2.774	0.032	98.857
KQ11	3.433	3.410	0.023	99.322	KQ91	2.182	2.118	0.064	97.087
KQ12	3.404	3.374	0.030	99.107	KQ92	3.556	3.606	-0.050	98.587
KQ13	2.919	2.978	-0.059	97.974	KQ93	2.392	2.403	-0.010	99.564
KQ14	3.099	3.095	0.004	99.869	KQ94	2.538	2.533	0.005	99.791
KQ15	3.222	3.178	0.044	98.624	KQ95	3.447	3.478	-0.031	99.111
KQ16	1.443	1.472	-0.029	97.990	KQ96	2.763	2.827	-0.065	97.656
KQ17	3.639	3.641	-0.002	99.932	KQ97	0.772	0.815	-0.042	94.517
KQ18	2.662	2.691	-0.029	98.928	KQ98	2.937	2.977	-0.040	98.642
KQ19	2.887	2.988	-0.101	96.514	KQ99	3.731	3.710	0.021	99.432
KQ20	2.627	2.654	-0.027	98.980	KQ100	1.076	1.104	-0.028	97.412
KQ21	3.325	3.397	-0.072	97.821	KQ101	2.102	2.052	0.050	97.638
KQ22	2.329	2.369	-0.040	98.280	KQ102	3.439	3.423	0.016	99.542
KQ23	2.186	2.164	0.022	98.982	KQ103	2.708	2.738	-0.031	98.868
KQ24	3.400	3.371	0.029	99.150	KQ104	3.606	3.609	-0.003	99.917
KQ25	2.263	2.332	-0.069	96.951	KQ105	0.297	0.347	-0.016	94.656
KQ26	4.134	4.170	-0.036	99.133	KQ106	2.680	2.747	-0.067	97.510
KQ27	2.482	2.534	-0.052	97.894	KQ107	2.265	2.265	0.001	99.962
KQ28	2.896	2.925	-0.029	98.989	KQ108	2.322	2.368	-0.045	98.043
KQ29	4.285	4.307	-0.022	99.492	KQ109	2.448	2.434	0.014	99.446
KQ30	3.804	3.808	-0.003	99.912	KQ110	4.031	4.021	0.009	99.766
KQ31	3.204	3.161	0.044	98.636	KQ111	3.169	3.157	0.012	99.635
KQ32	3.281	3.277	0.004	99.867	KQ112	3.263	3.254	0.010	99.703
KQ33	3.072	3.109	-0.037	98.794	KQ113	1.820	1.850	-0.029	98.382
KQ34	2.824	2.731	0.093	96.704	KQ114	3.884	3.881	0.003	99.914
KQ35	2.747	2.762	-0.015	99.462	KQ115	3.049	3.058	-0.009	99.696
KQ36	3.730	3.748	-0.018	99.509	KQ116	1.356	1.326	0.029	97.838
KQ37	2.558	2.559	-0.002	99.927	KQ117	3.551	3.539	0.012	99.667
KQ38	1.838	1.854	-0.017	99.098	KQ118	2.915	2.942	-0.027	99.083
KQ39	3.669	3.758	-0.088	97.590	KQ119	3.101	3.098	0.004	99.883
KQ40	2.197	2.232	-0.035	98.386	KQ120	1.966	1.915	0.051	97.417
KQ41	2.831	2.780	0.051	98.213	KQ121	2.687	2.611	0.076	97.163
KQ42	2.923	2.938	-0.015	99.498	KQ122	3.416	3.425	-0.009	99.740
KQ43	1.477	1.481	-0.004	99.730	KQ123	2.570	2.560	0.010	99.607
KQ44	3.402	3.356	0.046	98.649	KQ124	3.959	3.951	0.009	99.783
KQ45	4.334	4.343	-0.009	99.789	KQ125	3.116	3.112	0.004	99.863
KQ46	3.582	3.611	-0.029	99.187	KQ126	3.920	3.892	0.028	99.285
KQ47	1.633	1.662	-0.030	98.189	KQ127	0.459	0.501	-0.042	90.786
KQ48	1.977	2.001	-0.024	98.792	KQ128	3.126	3.151	-0.025	99.203
KQ49	2.907	2.923	-0.016	99.450	KQ129	2.610	2.667	-0.056	97.837
KQ50	3.114	3.070	0.044	98.588	KQ130	3.395	3.368	0.026	99.231
KQ51	1.278	1.244	0.034	97.377	KQ131	3.680	3.704	-0.025	99.324
KQ52	2.328	2.287	0.041	98.227	KQ132	4.122	4.176	-0.055	98.677
KQ53	1.804	1.801	0.003	99.841	KQ133	3.390	3.348	0.043	98.738
KQ54	3.472	3.450	0.022	99.355	KQ134	4.237	4.265	-0.029	99.325
KQ55	2.770	2.784	-0.014	99.481	KQ135	2.718	2.740	-0.022	99.205
KQ56	3.159	3.169	-0.010	99.690	KQ136	2.168	2.104	0.063	97.072
KQ57	3.360	3.379	-0.019	99.422	KQ137	1.279	1.259	0.020	98.447
KQ58	3.469	3.438	0.031	99.099	KQ138	3.524	3.537	-0.013	99.628
KQ59	3.135	3.139	-0.004	99.880	KQ139	2.202	2.125	0.076	96.527
KQ60	2.714	2.696	0.018	99.334	KQ140	2.207	2.250	-0.043	98.049
KQ61	3.078	3.029	0.049	98.394	KQ141	3.625	3.627	-0.002	99.939
KQ62	3.842	3.829	0.013	99.667	KQ142	3.340	3.305	0.035	98.953
KQ63	2.769	2.734	0.036	98.712	KQ143	3.292	3.298	-0.006	99.819
KQ64	3.617	3.630	-0.013	99.643	KQ144	1.349	1.308	0.041	96.995
KQ65	1.798	1.804	-0.005	99.710	KQ145	0.997	1.041	-0.044	95.562
KQ66	4.059	4.054	0.005	99.872	KQ146	3.147	3.080	0.067	97.884
KQ67	3.068	3.048	0.020	99.334	KQ147	2.549	2.589	-0.041	98.404
KQ68	2.704	2.671	0.033	98.780	KQ148	3.337	3.313	0.024	99.275
KQ69	3.979	4.007	-0.028	99.302	KQ149	3.930	3.943	-0.013	99.679
KQ70	3.565	3.556	0.010	99.732	KQ150	3.745	3.765	-0.019	99.481
KQ71	2.885	2.944	-0.059	97.945	KQ151	3.077	3.141	-0.064	97.925
KQ72	3.804	3.785	0.019	99.490	KQ152	3.277	3.110	0.167	94.899
KQ73	3.761	3.743	0.018	99.527	KQ153	3.508	3.504	0.004	99.891
KQ74	3.484	3.444	0.040	98.856	KQ154	2.979	2.988	-0.010	99.679
KQ75	3.745	3.736	0.010	99.740	KQ155	1.375	1.424	-0.049	96.411
KQ76	1.834	1.806	0.028	98.473	KQ156	2.296	2.242	0.054	97.638
KQ77	2.704	2.661	0.043	98.425	KQ157	3.699	3.692	0.008	99.788
KQ78	3.093	3.036	0.057	98.169	KQ158	3.517	3.548	-0.032	99.097
KQ79	2.922	2.925	-0.004	99.875	KQ159	3.308	3.217	0.090	97.278
KQ80	1.698	1.709	-0.011	99.356	KQ160	3.983	4.001	-0.018	99.541

附表9

图4

参考文献 90

[1]	Hitti Y, MacPherson S, Lefsrud M. Separate effects of sodium on germination in saline-sodic and alkaline forms at different concentrations. Plants, 2023, 12: 1234. doi: 10.3390/plants12061234
[2]	Fang S M, Hou X, Liang X L. Response mechanisms of plants under saline-alkali stress. Front Plant Sci, 2021, 12: 667458. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2021.667458
[3]	Custer G F. Unearthing opportunity amid declining plant-beneficial bacteria. Trends Plant Sci, 2024, 29: 834-836. doi: 10.1016/j.tplants.2024.02.011 pmid: 38461068
[4]	Wu J, Sun M T, Pang A Q, et al. Succinic acid synthesis regulated by succinyl-coenzyme a ligase (SUCLA) plays an important role in root response to alkaline salt stress in Leymus chinensis. Plant Physiol Biochem, 2025, 220: 109485. doi: 10.1016/j.plaphy.2025.109485
[5]	Lu Y, Zeng F J, Zhang Z H, et al. Differences in growth, ionomic and antioxidative enzymes system responded to neutral and alkali salt exposure in halophyte Haloxylon ammodendron seedlings. Plant Physiol Biochem, 2025, 220: 109492. doi: 10.1016/j.plaphy.2025.109492
[6]	Sharma M, Tisarum R, Kohli R K, et al. Inroads into saline-alkaline stress response in plants: unravelling morphological, physiological, biochemical, and molecular mechanisms. Planta, 2024, 259: 130. doi: 10.1007/s00425-024-04368-4 pmid: 38647733
[7]	Wang J Y, Li Q, Zhang M, et al. The high pH value of alkaline salt destroys the root membrane permeability of Reaumuria trigyna and leads to its serious physiological decline. J Plant Res, 2022, 135: 785-798. doi: 10.1007/s10265-022-01410-y
[8]	Qi Y T, Xie Y J, Ge M R, et al. Alkaline tolerance in plants: the AT1 gene and beyond. J Plant Physiol, 2024, 303: 154373. doi: 10.1016/j.jplph.2024.154373
[9]	Rao Y, Peng T, Xue S W. Mechanisms of plant saline-alkaline tolerance. J Plant Physiol, 2023, 281: 153916. doi: 10.1016/j.jplph.2023.153916
[10]	Cai X X, Jia B W, Sun M Z, et al. Insights into the regulation of wild soybean tolerance to salt-alkaline stress. Front Plant Sci, 2022, 13: 1002302. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2022.1002302
[11]	He J Y, Hao Y R, He Y Q, et al. Genome-wide associated study identifies FtPMEI13 gene conferring drought resistance in Tartary buckwheat. Plant J, 2024, 120: 2398-2419. doi: 10.1111/tpj.v120.6
[12]	Kreft I, Germ M, Golob A, et al. Phytochemistry, bioactivities of metabolites, and traditional uses of Fagopyrum tataricum. Molecules, 2022, 27: 7101. doi: 10.3390/molecules27207101
[13]	He Y Q, Zhang K X, Shi Y L, et al. Genomic insight into the origin, domestication, dispersal, diversification and human selection of Tartary buckwheat. Genome Biol, 2024, 25: 61. doi: 10.1186/s13059-024-03203-z pmid: 38414075
[14]	范志强, 王安妮, 牛浩然, 等. 锌离子胁迫对5种观赏植物种子萌发的影响. 西安文理学院学报(自然科学版), 2025, 28(3): 56-60.
	Fan Z Q, Wang A N, Niu H R, et al. The effect of zinc ion stress on seed germination in five ornamental plants. J Xi’an Univ Arts Sci (Nat Sci Edn), 2025, 28(3): 56-60 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[15]	Wang X D, Shen H L, Yang L. The response of hormones, reactive oxygen species and nitric oxide in the polyethylene-glycol- promoted, salt-alkali-stress-induced embryo germination of Sorbus pohuashanensis. Int J Mol Sci, 2024, 25: 5128. doi: 10.3390/ijms25105128
[16]	李春花, 加央多拉, 吴晗, 等. 46份甜荞种质萌发期耐盐资源评价与筛选. 种子, 2024, 43(5): 1-6.
	Li C H, Jia Y D L, Wu H, et al. Evaluation and screening of 46 buckwheat germplasm for salt tolerance at germination stage. Seed, 2024, 43(5): 1-6 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[17]	周超凡, 宋炘眙, 颜宏金, 等. 荞麦种子萌发期耐旱和耐盐碱性综合评价. 西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版), 2025, 53(8): 45-54.
	Zhou C F, Song X Y, Yan H J, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of drought and salinity tolerance of buckwheat seeds during germination period. J Northwest A&F Univ (Nat Sci Edn), 2025, 53(8): 45-54 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[18]	Zhao J L, Wu Q, Wu H L, et al. FtNAC31, a Tartary buckwheat NAC transcription factor, enhances salt and drought tolerance in transgenic Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol Biochem, 2022, 191: 20-33. doi: 10.1016/j.plaphy.2022.09.016
[19]	Fang Y, Wang S, Wu H L, et al. Genome-wide identification of ATG gene family members in Fagopyrum tataricum and their expression during stress responses. Int J Mol Sci, 2022, 23: 14845. doi: 10.3390/ijms232314845
[20]	才晓溪, 胡冰霜, 沈阳, 等. GsERF6基因过表达对水稻耐盐碱性的影响. 作物学报, 2023, 49: 561-569. doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2023.22008
	Cai X X, Hu B S, Shen Y, et al. Effects of GsERF6 gene overexpression on salinity tolerance in rice. Acta Agron Sin, 2023, 49: 561-569 (in Chinese with English abstract). doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2023.22008
[21]	豆昕桐, 王英杰, 王华忠, 等. 耐盐和盐敏感型小麦品种对NaCl胁迫的生理响应及耐盐性差异. 生态学报, 2021, 41: 4976-4992.
	Dou X T, Wang Y J, Wang H Z, et al. Physiological response to NaCl stress and differences in salt tolerance in salt-tolerant and salt-sensitive wheat cultivars. Acta Ecol Sin, 2021, 41: 4976-4992 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[22]	王宏凯, 赵靖怡, 郭宏娜, 等. 小麦种质资源耐盐性鉴定. 麦类作物学报, 2024, 44: 253-260.
	Wang H K, Zhao J Y, Guo H N, et al. Identification of salt tolerance in wheat germplasm resources. J Triticeae Crops, 2024, 44: 253-260 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[23]	李雪婷, 任昊, 王洪章, 等. 盐胁迫对不同耐盐型玉米品种叶片光合性能和干物质积累与分配的影响. 作物学报, 2025, 51: 1091-1101. doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2025.43032
	Li X T, Ren H, Wang H Z, et al. Effects of salt stress on leaf photosynthetic performance and dry matter accumulation and partitioning in different salt-tolerant maize cultivars. Acta Agron Sin, 2025, 51: 1091-1101 (in Chinese with English abstract). doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2025.43032
[24]	Flowers T J, Munns R, Colmer T D. Sodium chloride toxicity and the cellular basis of salt tolerance in halophytes. Ann Bot, 2015, 115: 419-431. doi: 10.1093/aob/mcu217
[25]	Zhao X Y, Gao J L, Yu X F, et al. Evaluation of the microbial community in various saline alkaline-soils driven by soil factors of the Hetao Plain, Inner Mongolia. Sci Rep, 2024, 14: 28931. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-80328-y
[26]	Li J J, Che Y J, Chen S Y, et al. Bacillus tropicus YJ33 and Medicago sativa L. synergistically enhance soil aggregate stability in saline-alkali environments. Microorganisms, 2025, 13: 1291. doi: 10.3390/microorganisms13061291
[27]	Mandal A K, Arora S, Sharma P C, et al. Spatial assessment, mapping, and characterization of salt-affected soils in Uttar Pradesh state of the Gangetic plain (IGP), India, for planning reclamation and management. Environ Monit Assess, 2025, 197: 739. doi: 10.1007/s10661-025-14158-4 pmid: 40481355
[28]	Gelu G, Komai K, Dane C, et al. Investigating the salinity distribution using field measurements in the semi-arid region of Southern Ethiopia. Environ Monit Assess, 2025, 197: 159. doi: 10.1007/s10661-024-13576-0 pmid: 39794545
[29]	Chen Y, Lou S, Chen X, et al. Effects of brackish water irrigation with different exogenous salt concentrations on the growth and rhizosphere salinity of Lycium barbarum. Sci Rep, 2024, 14: 21554. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-72498-6 pmid: 39284876
[30]	Lu Q, Niu X J, Zhang M C, et al. Genome-wide association study of seed dormancy and the genomic consequences of improvement footprints in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Front Plant Sci, 2018, 8: 2213. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2017.02213
[31]	Qi W W, Ma H Y, Li S Y, et al. Seed germination and seedling growth in Suaeda salsa (Linn.) Pall. (Amaranthaceae) demonstrate varying salinity tolerance among different provenances. Biology, 2023, 12: 1343. doi: 10.3390/biology12101343
[32]	Su W N, Qiu J Q, Soufan W, et al. Synergistic effects of melatonin and glycine betaine on seed germination, seedling growth, and biochemical attributes of maize under salinity stress. Physiol Plant, 2024, 176: e14514.
[33]	Li X, Li J J, Su H Y, et al. Physiological and transcriptional responses of Apocynum venetum to salt stress at the seed germination stage. Int J Mol Sci, 2023, 24: 3623. doi: 10.3390/ijms24043623
[34]	Xu G W, Cheng Y J, Wang X Q, et al. Identification of single nucleotide polymorphic loci and candidate genes for seed germination percentage in okra under salt and no-salt stresses by genome-wide association study. Plants, 2024, 13: 588. doi: 10.3390/plants13050588
[35]	樊丽琴, 杨建国, 许兴, 等. 宁夏引黄灌区盐碱地土壤盐分特征及相关性. 中国农学通报, 2012, 28(35): 221-225.
	Fan L Q, Yang J G, Xu X, et al. Characterization and correlation of soil salinity in saline-alkaline soils of the Yinhuang irrigation district, Ningxia. Chin Agric Sci Bull, 2012, 28(35): 221-225 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[36]	Song J Q, Zhao L T, Ma Y M, et al. Response of seed germination, seedling growth and physiological characteristics to alkali stress in halophyte Suaeda liaotungensis. J Plant Res, 2024, 137: 1137-1149. doi: 10.1007/s10265-024-01568-7
[37]	Shi D C, Wang D L. Effects of various salt-alkaline mixed stresses on Aneurolepidium chinense (Trin.) Kitag. Plant Soil, 2005, 271: 15-26. doi: 10.1007/s11104-004-1307-z
[38]	Fan Y P, Wang N, Wang S, et al. GhGLDH35A gene-mediated ROS homeostasis and stomatal movement via the ascorbic acid pathway confers alkaline stress tolerance. J Adv Res, Published online [2025-06-15], https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jare.2025.06.018.
[39]	Khan M M, Rahman M M, Hasan M M, et al. Assessment of the salt tolerance of diverse bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) genotypes during the early growth stage under hydroponic culture conditions. Heliyon, 2024, 10: e29042.
[40]	王洋, 张瑞, 刘永昊, 等. 水稻对盐胁迫的响应及耐盐机理研究进展. 中国水稻科学, 2022, 36(2): 105-117. doi: 10.16819/j.1001-7216.2022.210609
	Wang Y, Zhang R, Liu Y H, et al. Advances in the response of rice to salt stress and the mechanism of salt tolerance. Chin J Rice Sci, 2022, 36(2): 105-117 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[41]	Kruthika N, Jithesh M N. Morpho-physiological profiling of rice (Oryza sativa) genotypes at germination stage with contrasting tolerance to salinity stress. J Plant Res, 2023, 136: 907-930. doi: 10.1007/s10265-023-01491-3 pmid: 37702838
[42]	Song J Q, Wang H F, Chu R W, et al. Differences in physiological characteristics, seed germination, and seedling establishment in response to salt stress between dimorphic seeds in the halophyte Suaeda liaotungensis. Plants, 2023, 12: 1408. doi: 10.3390/plants12061408
[43]	Singh A, Khare S, Niharika, et al. Sulfur and phosphorus transporters in plants: Integrating mechanisms for optimized nutrient supply. Plant Physiol Biochem, 2025, 224: 109918. doi: 10.1016/j.plaphy.2025.109918
[44]	Cheng C, Liu J X, Wang Z W, et al. Analysis of effect of compound salt stress on seed germination and salt tolerance analysis of pepper (Capsicum annuum L.). J Vis Exp, 2022, 189: e64702.
[45]	Cao Y, Hao F, Li J P, et al. Integrated transcriptome and metabolome analyses reveal complex oxidative damage mechanisms in rice seedling roots under different carbonate stresses. Antioxidants, 2025, 14: 658. doi: 10.3390/antiox14060658
[46]	Yaşar M. Sensitivity of different flax (Linum usitatissimum L.) genotypes to salinity determined by GE biplot. Saudi J Biol Sci, 2023, 30: 103592. doi: 10.1016/j.sjbs.2023.103592
[47]	Barwal S K, Shah S H, Pawar A, et al. Mechanistic insights of salicylic acid-mediated salt stress tolerance in Zea mays L. seedlings. Heliyon, 2024, 10: e34486.
[48]	D’Hooghe P, Kopriva S, Avice J C, et al. Tuning of sulfur flow and sulfur seed metabolism in oilseed rape under sulfate-limited conditions. J Exp Bot, 2025, 76: 2278-2296. doi: 10.1093/jxb/eraf028
[49]	秦敬泽, 秦泽峰, 倪刚, 等. AMF和PGPR单独或“跨界”互作促进植物耐盐性的研究进展. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2024, 30: 1354-1366.
	Qin J Z, Qin Z F, Ni G, et al. Progress of AMF and PGPR alone or in “cross-border” interactions to promote plant salt tolerance. J Plant Nutr Fert, 2024, 30: 1354-1366 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[50]	李佳钰, 刘兴和, 魏佳吉, 等. 土壤改良剂对盐碱土性质及草地早熟禾生理生长特性的影响. 草原与草坪, 2025, 45(1): 227-235.
	Li J Y, Liu X H, Wei J J, et al. Effects of soil amendments on saline soil properties and physiological growth characteristics of grassland morning glory. Grassland Turf, 2025, 45(1): 227-235 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[51]	Dong Z D, Huang J, Qi T, et al. Effects of plant regulators on the seed germination and antioxidant enzyme activity of cotton under compound salt stress. Plants, 2023, 12: 4112. doi: 10.3390/plants12244112
[52]	Zhang R, Zhang H Z, Wang L, et al. Effect of salt-alkali stress on seed germination of the halophyte Halostachys caspica. Sci Rep, 2024, 14: 13199. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-61737-5 pmid: 38851793
[53]	Li X B, Wang L, Wang H Y, et al. Dynamic physiology and transcriptomics revealed the alleviation effect of melatonin on Reaumuria trigyna under continuous alkaline salt stress. Front Plant Sci, 2025, 15: 1486436. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2024.1486436
[54]	Li J, Yang Y Q. How do plants maintain pH and ion homeostasis under saline-alkali stress? Front Plant Sci, 2023, 14: 1217193. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2023.1217193
[55]	Wang P T, Ma J F. Knockout of a gene encoding a Gγ protein boosts alkaline tolerance in cereal crops. aBIOTECH, 2023, 4: 180-183. doi: 10.1007/s42994-023-00106-8 pmid: 37581019
[56]	Balakrishnan J, Srinivas Ravi M, Ganesan J, et al. Enzyme evolution and antioxidant defense in salt-stressed Kunthali rice: a pathway to sustainable biocatalytic solutions for crop improvement. Int J Biol Macromol, 2025, 308: 142385. doi: 10.1016/j.ijbiomac.2025.142385
[57]	Yao X, Zhou M L, Ruan J J, et al. Physiological and biochemical regulation mechanism of exogenous hydrogen peroxide in alleviating NaCl stress toxicity in Tartary buckwheat (Fagopyrum tataricum(L.) gaertn). Int J Mol Sci, 2022, 23: 10698. doi: 10.3390/ijms231810698
[58]	姜睿, 刘文瑜, 王旺田, 等. 50份藜麦种质材料萌发期耐低温综合评价. 草业科学,网络首发, [2025-06-20], https://link.cnki.net/urlid/62.1069.S.20250619.1703.002.
	Jiang R, Liu W Y, Wang W T, et al. Comprehensive evaluation of low-temperature tolerance during the germination period of 50 quinoa germplasm materials. Pratacult Sci, Published online, [2025-06-20], https://link.cnki.net/urlid/62.1069.S.20250619.1703.002 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[59]	Choudhary A, Kaur N, Sharma A, et al. Evaluation and screening of elite wheat germplasm for salinity stress at the seedling phase. Physiol Plant, 2021, 173: 2207-2215. doi: 10.1111/ppl.13571 pmid: 34549444
[60]	刘春荣, 张国新, 王秀萍. 主成分分析及隶属函数法综合评价玉米苗期耐盐性. 安徽农业科学, 2015, 43(28): 13-14.
	Liu C R, Zhang G X, Wang X P. Principal component analysis and membership function method to evaluate salt tolerance in seedling stage of corn. J Anhui Agric Sci, 2015, 43(28): 13-14 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[61]	王智兰, 唐楚楚, 夏美琳, 等. 谷子萌发期耐盐突变体的筛选和鉴定. 核农学报, 2025, 39: 1101-1109. doi: 10.11869/j.issn.1000-8551.2025.06.1101
	Wang Z L, Tang C C, Xia M L, et al. Screening and identification of salt-tolerant mutants during the germination stage of foxtail millet. J Nucl Agric Sci, 2025, 39: 1101-1109 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[62]	Xue J K, Sun H, Zhou X M, et al. Exploration of the regulatory pathways and key genes involved in the response to saline-alkali stress in Betula platyphylla via RNA-seq analysis. Plants, 2023, 12: 2435. doi: 10.3390/plants12132435
[63]	Kumari A, Fatnani D, Seth C S, et al. Unravelling the metabolic signatures and associated pathways underlying saline-alkali stress resilience in the halophyte Salvadora persica. Physiol Plant, 2025, 177: e70114.
[64]	Liu L, Si L, Zhang L S, et al. Metabolomics and transcriptomics analysis revealed the response mechanism of alfalfa to combined cold and saline-alkali stress. Plant J, 2024, 119: 1900-1919. doi: 10.1111/tpj.v119.4
[65]	Song Y J, Feng J C, Liu D M, et al. Different phenylalanine pathway responses to cold stress based on metabolomics and transcriptomics in Tartary buckwheat landraces. J Agric Food Chem, 2022, 70: 687-698. doi: 10.1021/acs.jafc.1c06915
[66]	刘畅.外源褪黑素对碱胁迫下谷子的缓解效应. 黑龙江八一农垦大学硕士学位论文, 黑龙江大庆, 2025.
	Liu C. The Alleviating Effect of Exogenous Melatonin on Alkaline Stress in Foxtail Millet. MS Thesis of Heilongjiang Bayi Agricultural University, Daqing, Heilongjiang, China, 2025 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[67]	郭瑞锋, 张永福, 任月梅, 等. 混合盐碱胁迫对谷子萌发、幼芽生长的影响及耐盐碱品种筛选. 作物杂志, 2017(4): 63-66.
	Guo R F, Zhang Y F, Ren Y M, et al. The effects of mixed salt-alkali stress on the germination and seedling growth of millet and the screening of salt-alkali tolerant varieties. Crops, 2017(4): 63-66 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[68]	尹尚军, 颜宏, 石德成, 等. 中性盐(NaCl)和碱性盐(Na₂CO₃)胁迫下小麦苗的生理反应. 通化师院学报, 1997, 18(5): 42-45.
	Yin S J, Yan H, Shi D C, et al. Physiological responses of wheat seedlings under neutral salt (NaCl) and alkaline salt (Na₂CO₃) stress. J Tonghua Teach Coll, 1997, 18(5): 42-45 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[69]	张宝泽, 赵可夫, 李淑梅. 盐(NaCl)和碱(Na₂CO₃)对高粱幼苗生长效应的比较研究. 垦殖与稻作, 1996(1): 35-36.
	Zhang B Z, Zhao K F, Li S M. A Comparative study on the effects of salt (NaCl) and alkali (Na₂CO₃) on the growth of sorghum seedlings. Reclam Rice Cult, 1996(1): 35-36 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[70]	石德成, 殷立娟. 盐(NaCl)与碱(Na₂CO₃)对星星草胁迫作用的差异. 植物学报, 1993, 35: 144-149.
	Shi D C, Yin L J. Differences in the effects of salt (NaCl) and alkali (Na₂CO₃) on stress in star grass. J Integr Plant Biol, 1993, 35: 144-149 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[71]	石德成, 赵可夫. NaCl、Na₂CO₃胁迫下星星草根际K⁺、Na⁺、Ca²⁺的生理行为. 应用与环境生物学报, 1997, 3: 112-118.
	Shi D C, Zhao K F. Physiological behavior of K⁺, Na⁺, and Ca²⁺ in the rhizosphere of star grass under NaCl and Na₂CO₃ stress. Chin J Appl Environ Biol, 1997, 3: 112-118 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[72]	Wei X L, Wang J, Xu C T, et al. Analysis of germination characteristics and metabolome of Medicago ruthenica in response to saline-alkali stress. Front Plant Sci, 2025, 16: 1592555. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2025.1592555
[73]	Miljaković D, Marinković J, Tamindžić G, et al. Bio-priming of soybean with Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Bacillus megaterium: strategy to improve seed germination and the initial seedling growth. Plants, 2022, 11: 1927. doi: 10.3390/plants11151927
[74]	李春花, 孙墨可, 吴晗, 等. 盐碱胁迫对荞麦种子萌发及幼苗生长的影响. 种子, 2023, 42(11): 54-60.
	Li C H, Sun M K, Wu H, et al. The effect of saline-alkali stress on buckwheat seed germination and seedling growth. Seed, 2023, 42(11): 54-60 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[75]	Li H Y, Lyu Q Y, Liu A K, et al. Comparative metabolomics study of Tartary (Fagopyrum tataricum (L.) Gaertn) and common (Fagopyrum esculentum (L.) buckwheat seeds. Food Chem, 2022, 371: 131125. doi: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2021.131125
[76]	Zargar S M, Hami A, Manzoor M, et al. Buckwheat OMICS: present status and future prospects. Crit Rev Biotechnol, 2024, 44: 717-734. doi: 10.1080/07388551.2023.2229511
[77]	Guo M F, Zong J, Zhang J X, et al. Effects of temperature and drought stress on the seed germination of a peatland lily (Lilium concolor var.megalanthum. Front Plant Sci, 2024, 15: 1462655. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2024.1462655
[78]	Zhang J Q, Zheng D F, Feng N J, et al. Regulation of exogenous strigolactone on storage substance metabolism and endogenous hormone levels in the early germination stage of rice seeds under salt stress. Antioxidants, 2024, 14: 22. doi: 10.3390/antiox14010022
[79]	Ramadan E, Freeg H A, Shalaby N, et al. Response of nine Triticale genotypes to different salt concentrations at the germination and early seedling stages. PeerJ, 2023, 11: e16256.
[80]	Zhang Y Y, Li Y C, Liu H, et al. Effect of exogenous melatonin on corn seed germination and seedling salt damage mitigation under NaCl stress. Plants, 2025, 14: 1139. doi: 10.3390/plants14071139
[81]	张静, 高文博, 晏林, 等. 燕麦种质资源耐盐碱性鉴定评价及耐盐碱种质筛选. 作物学报, 2023, 49: 1551-1561. doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2023.21032
	Zhang J, Gao W B, Yan L, et al. Evaluation of salinity tolerance identification of oat germplasm resources and screening of salinity tolerant germplasm. Acta Agron Sin, 2023, 49: 1551-1561 (in Chinese with English abstract). doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2023.21032
[82]	徐宁, 陈冰嬬, 王明海, 等. 绿豆品种资源萌发期耐碱性鉴定. 作物学报, 2017, 43: 112-121. doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2017.00112
	Xu N, Chen B R, Wang M H, et al. Alkaline tolerance assessment of mung bean varieties during the germination period. Acta Agron Sin, 2017, 43: 112-121 (in Chinese with English abstract). doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2017.00112
[83]	Zhong L Y, Niu B, Xiang D B, et al. Endophytic fungi in buckwheat seeds: exploring links with flavonoid accumulation. Front Microbiol, 2024, 15: 1353763. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2024.1353763
[84]	Ye X L, Li Q, Liu C Y, et al. Transcriptomic, cytological, and physiological analyses reveal the potential regulatory mechanism in Tartary buckwheat under cadmium stress. Front Plant Sci, 2022, 13: 1004802. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2022.1004802
[85]	Dong Y L, Wang N, Wang S M, et al. A review: the nutrition components, active substances and flavonoid accumulation of Tartary buckwheat sprouts and innovative physical technology for seeds germinating. Front Nutr, 2023, 10: 1168361. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2023.1168361
[86]	Zhou Q Y, He P Y, Tang J G, et al. Increasing planting density can improve the yield of Tartary buckwheat. Front Plant Sci, 2023, 14: 1313181. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2023.1313181
[87]	Huang X Y, Leng J L, Liu C M, et al. Exogenous melatonin enhances the continuous cropping tolerance of Tartary buckwheat (Fagopyrum tataricum) by regulating the antioxidant defense system. Physiol Plant, 2024, 176: e14524.
[88]	Singh L, Pruthi R, Chapagain S, et al. Genome-wide association study identified candidate genes for alkalinity tolerance in rice. Plants, 2023, 12: 2206. doi: 10.3390/plants12112206
[89]	虞晓芬, 傅玳. 多指标综合评价方法综述. 统计与决策, 2004(11): 119-121.
	Yu X F, Fu D. Summary of multi-index comprehensive evaluation methods. Stat Decis, 2004(11): 119-121 (in Chinese).
[90]	蒋优, 马雪融, 张博, 等. 苏丹草种子萌发期耐盐性评价及耐盐种质筛选. 作物学报, 2025, 51: 835-844. doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2025.44099
	Jiang Y, Ma X R, Zhang B, et al. Evaluation of salt tolerance during seed germination and screening of salt-tolerant germplasm of Sudan grass. Acta Agron Sin, 2025, 51: 835-844 (in Chinese with English abstract). doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2025.44099

Metrics

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed

类型 Type	非盐碱土Non-saline soil			轻度盐碱土Mildly saline soil			中度盐碱土Moderately saline soil
类型 Type	电导率 EC (dS m^-1)	对应浓度梯度CCG (%)	理论盐度 TS (mmol L^-1)	电导率 EC (dS m^-1)	对应浓度梯度CCG (%)	理论盐度TS (mmol L^-1)	电导率 EC (dS m^-1)	对应浓度梯度CCG (%)	理论盐度TS (mmol L^-1)
NaCl	<2.0	≤0.15	≤2.90	2.0-4.0	0.25-0.35	4.27-6.75	4.00-8.00	≥0.45	7.71-8.62
Na₂SO₄	<2.0	≤0.15	≤1.21	2.0-4.0	0.25-0.35	1.72-2.83	4.00-8.00	≥0.45	3.18-3.56
NaHCO₃	<0.9	≤0.05	≤0.77	0.9-1.8	0.10-0.15	1.16-2.11	1.80-2.20	≥0.20	≥2.32
Na₂CO₃	<0.9	≤0.50	≤0.64	0.9-2.4	0.15-0.25	0.96-1.92	2.40-3.00	≥0.20	≥1.92
农业生产影响Agricultural production impacts	适宜作物生长 Suitable for crop growth			轻微抑制根系吸收 Slightly inhibits root absorption			生长受阻, 产量下降 Growth stunted, yield reduced

单盐 Salt	浓度 Concentration (%)	发芽率 Germination rate (%)	发芽指数 Germination index	发芽势 Germination potential (%)	活力指数 Vigor index	相对盐害率 Relative salt injury rate (%)
NaCl	0	92.04±3.23 b	12.51±0.62 b	85.45±5.13 b	107.15±30.00 b	0
	0.15	95.36±4.98 a	13.32±0.89 a	92.14±6.82 a	114.12±16.97 a	-3.61
	0.25	95.92±6.97 a	13.47±1.19 a	93.50±9.06 a	113.49±25.88 a	-4.22
	0.35	86.00±5.29 c	11.67±0.82 c	79.79±6.17 c	58.33±16.00 c	6.56
	0.45	82.44±5.53 d	11.17±0.83 d	76.38±6.14 d	39.46±13.48 d	10.43
	F-value	7.51^**	7.75^**	8.35^**	1.98^**
Na₂SO₄	0	92.04±3.23 b	12.51±0.62 b	85.45±5.13 b	107.15±30.00 a	0
	0.15	93.39±5.96 ab	12.94±0.97 a	89.36±7.33 a	106.73±17.73 a	-1.47
	0.25	96.03±8.01 a	13.12±1.33 a	90.82±9.81 a	106.15±27.39 a	-4.34
	0.35	82.39±5.95 c	11.15±0.87 c	76.46±6.30 c	52.07±15.20 b	10.48
	0.45	78.85±5.96 d	10.68±0.87 d	72.96±6.36 d	35.24±12.17 c	14.33
	F-value	1.73^**	7.40^**	8.37^**	1.94^**
NaHCO₃	0	92.04±3.23 a	12.51±0.62 a	85.45±5.13 b	107.15±30.00 a	0
	0.05	91.25±7.47 a	12.58±1.12 a	86.62±8.19 ab	101.18±18.45 b	0.88
	0.10	91.76±9.62 a	12.72±1.46 a	87.91±9.98 a	100.00±27.51 b	0.33
	0.15	78.49±6.51 b	10.64±0.92 b	72.73±6.65 c	46.76±12.85 c	14.74
	0.20	74.94±6.62 c	10.14±0.93 c	69.24±6.67 d	31.73±10.63 d	18.60
	F-value	7.01^**	7.52^**	8.16^**	1.76^**
Na₂CO₃	0	92.04±3.33 a	12.51±0.67 a	85.45±5.40 a	107.15±30.00 a	0
	0.05	90.23±9.98 b	12.39±1.46 a	85.20±10.42 a	95.28±24.52 b	1.97
	0.10	88.33±9.28 c	12.12±1.44 b	83.50±9.83 b	91.84±24.41 c	4.03
	0.15	74.85±6.86 d	10.12±0.98 c	69.09±6.87 c	41.28±12.06 d	18.68
	0.20	71.24±7.27 e	9.62±1.01 d	65.60±7.01 d	28.21±9.65 e	22.60
	F-value	6.33^**	6.76^**	7.53^**	1.68^**

指标 Index	NaCl胁迫 NaCl stress		Na₂SO₄胁迫 Na₂SO₄ stress		NaHCO₃胁迫 NaHCO₃stress		Na₂CO₃胁迫 Na₂CO₃ stress
指标 Index	I	II	I	II	I	II	I	II
X₁	0.861	-0.382	0.892	-0.313	0.861	-0.399	0.867	-0.380
X₂	0.714	-0.407	0.716	-0.438	0.487	-0.642	0.552	-0.625
X₃	0.878	-0.397	0.906	-0.336	0.867	-0.403	0.868	-0.396
X₄	0.711	-0.424	0.758	-0.351	0.711	-0.449	0.738	-0.411
X₅	0.571	0.799	0.551	0.795	0.658	0.729	0.685	0.706
X₆	0.588	0.754	0.454	0.679	0.657	0.703	0.694	0.674
X₇	0.588	0.803	0.554	0.800	0.666	0.735	0.698	0.706
X₈	0.960	-0.032	0.963	0.037	0.970	-0.020	0.970	-0.015
X₉	0.668	-0.106	0.704	0.037	0.694	-0.127	0.706	-0.152

盐胁迫下苦荞萌发期耐盐碱性评价及种质筛选

Evaluation of salinity tolerance and germplasm screening of buckwheat during germination under salt stress

RichHTML

PDF

文章附图附表

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

图/表 19

参考文献 90

相关文章 15

Metrics

本文评价

推荐阅读 0

关于本刊

在线期刊

作者中心

相关单位

联系我们

处理 Treatment	主成分 Principal component	特征值 Eigen value	方差贡献率 Variance contribution rate (%)	累计方差贡献率 Cumulative contribution rate of variance (%)
NaCl胁迫 NaCl stress	I	4.91	54.60	54.60
NaCl胁迫 NaCl stress	II	2.51	27.90	82.50
Na₂SO₄胁迫 Na₂SO₄stress	I	4.94	54.91	54.91
Na₂SO₄胁迫 Na₂SO₄stress	II	2.27	25.21	80.12
NaHCO₃胁迫 NaHCO₃ stress	I	4.97	55.17	55.17
NaHCO₃胁迫 NaHCO₃ stress	II	2.52	27.96	83.13
Na₂CO₃胁迫 Na₂CO₃ stress	I	5.23	58.13	58.13
Na₂CO₃胁迫 Na₂CO₃ stress	II	2.33	25.94	84.07

单盐 Salt	浓度 Concentration (%)	综合指标值 Value of composite indicator		隶属函数值 Value of the affiliation function		D值 D-value	排序 Rank
单盐 Salt	浓度 Concentration (%)	I	II	I	II	D值 D-value	排序 Rank
NaCl	0	4.56	-0.03	3.03	-0.01	3.02	3
	0.15	5.50	0.50	3.65	0.17	3.83	2
	0.25	5.61	0.60	3.73	0.21	3.94	1
	0.35	1.74	0.04	1.16	0.01	1.17	4
	0.45	0.06	-0.01	0.04	0	0.04	5
	权重W_i			0.66	0.34
Na₂SO₄	0	5.00	0.38	3.43	0.12	3.55	3
	0.15	5.38	0.70	3.69	0.22	3.91	2
	0.25	5.50	0.83	3.77	0.26	4.03	1
	0.35	1.63	0.12	1.12	0.04	1.15	4
	0.45	0.03	0.01	0.02	0	0.03	5
	权重W_i			0.69	0.31
NaHCO₃	0	5.42	-0.05	3.60	-0.02	3.58	3
	0.05	5.46	0.02	3.62	0.01	3.63	2
	0.10	5.54	0.14	3.68	0.05	3.72	1
NaHCO₃	0.15	1.55	-0.11	1.03	-0.04	0.99	4
	0.20	0.02	-0.01	0.01	0.00	0.01	5
	权重W_i			0.66	0.34
Na₂CO₃	0	5.99	0.20	4.15	0.06	4.21	1
	0.05	5.72	0.31	3.95	0.09	4.04	2
	0.10	5.39	0.19	3.73	0.06	3.79	3
	0.15	1.50	-0.09	1.04	-0.03	1.01	4
	0.20	0.02	0	0.01	0	0.01	5
	权重W_i			0.69	0.31

[1]	徐建霞, 丁延庆, 曹宁, 程斌, 高旭, 李文贞, 王若若, 王磊, 张立异. 397份高粱种质资源在贵州表型多样性分析及综合评价[J]. 作物学报, 2026, 52(4): 1073-1087.
[2]	刘迪, 黎瑞源, 石茂竹, 李洪有, 陈庆富, 石桃雄. 苦荞半矮秆突变体sd3的表型鉴定及转录组分析[J]. 作物学报, 2026, 52(1): 316-328.
[3]	王菲菲, 张胜忠, 杨贵华, 苗华荣, 胡晓辉, 张则林, 刘莎莎, 乔利仙, 单世华, 陈静. 331份花生种质苗期耐盐性综合评价和强耐盐种质鉴选[J]. 作物学报, 2026, 52(1): 279-294.
[4]	尹丽娜, 张锐, 陈国欢, 白磊, 李俊, 郭华春, 杨芳. 不同马铃薯品种块茎创伤愈合能力的比较[J]. 作物学报, 2025, 51(9): 2399-2411.
[5]	文璇, 钟秀丽, 王尚文, 金涛, 彭君, 刘恩科. 基于耐性指数的青稞苗期耐低氮种质筛选及不同氮效率类型综合评价[J]. 作物学报, 2025, 51(7): 1949-1958.
[6]	蒋优, 马雪融, 张博, 李陈建. 苏丹草种子萌发期耐盐性评价及耐盐种质筛选[J]. 作物学报, 2025, 51(3): 835-844.
[7]	葛家豪, 雷欣月, 王清明, 韩慧冰, 李少飞, 王琦璇, 冯佰利, 高金锋. 苦荞苗期耐低磷种质筛选及耐低磷综合评价[J]. 作物学报, 2025, 51(11): 2911-2922.
[8]	闫锋, 董扬, 李清泉, 赵富阳, 侯晓敏, 刘洋, 李青超, 赵蕾, 范国权, 刘凯. 谷子育成品种萌芽期耐冷性综合评价[J]. 作物学报, 2024, 50(9): 2207-2218.
[9]	聂波涛, 刘德泉, 陈健, 崔正果, 侯云龙, 陈亮, 邱红梅, 王跃强. 北方春大豆品种农艺和品质性状分析与综合评价[J]. 作物学报, 2024, 50(9): 2248-2266.
[10]	刘欣玥, 郭潇阳, 王欣茹, 辛大伟, 关荣霞, 邱丽娟. 大豆萌发期耐盐性鉴定方法建立及耐盐大豆资源筛选[J]. 作物学报, 2024, 50(8): 2122-2130.
[11]	李晓菲, 高华伟, 广慧, 石宇欣, 谷勇哲, 齐照明, 邱丽娟. 大豆种质资源萌发期耐莠去津鉴定评价及优异种质筛选[J]. 作物学报, 2024, 50(7): 1699-1709.
[12]	李航, 刘丽, 黄乾, 刘文豪, 司爱君, 孔宪辉, 王旭文, 赵福相, 梅拥军, 余渝. 棉花种质资源萌发期耐盐性鉴定及筛选[J]. 作物学报, 2024, 50(5): 1147-1157.
[13]	许乃银, 王扬, 王丹涛, 宁贺佳, 杨晓妮, 乔银桃. 棉花纤维质量指数的构建与WGT双标图分析[J]. 作物学报, 2023, 49(5): 1262-1271.
[14]	郭宏, 于霁雯, 裴文锋, 关永虎, 李航, 李长喜, 刘金伟, 王伟, 王宝全, 梅拥军. 南疆陆地棉杂种F₂的遗传分析及遗传主效聚类[J]. 作物学报, 2023, 49(3): 608-621.
[15]	孟雨, 田文仲, 温鹏飞, 丁志强, 张学品, 贺利, 段剑钊, 刘万代, 郭天财, 冯伟. 基于不同发育阶段协同的小麦品种抗旱性综合评判[J]. 作物学报, 2023, 49(2): 570-582.